1. POTS aims at "5 nines" reliability. [1]
2. > the chances of them all being down at once is far lower than your POTS line being down.
That depends crucially on the correlation. If there are common fault modes (such as: internet down), the probability might be way higher. (Remember, it used to be common wisdom that it was possible that one or two home owners won't be able to pay their mortgages, but the probability that many will be unable to pay their mortgages is so low that all these MBS and CDO's can be rated AAA...)
3. EDIT to add: Of course, adding communication options can only increase the probability that you can reach your emergency provider, but there's a reason that Skype etc. used to come with these big disclaimers that they're no replacement for POTS, namely the excellent reliability of POTS.
[1] "Although POTS provides limited features, low bandwidth, and no mobile capabilities, it provides greater reliability than other telephony systems (mobile phone, VoIP, etc.). Many telephone service providers attempt to achieve dial-tone availability more than 99.999% of the time the telephone is taken off-hook. This is an often cited benchmark in marketing and systems-engineering comparisons, called the "five nines" reliability standard."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plain_old_telephone_service#Re...