However, if something were to come along that uses the user's local webview instead and provided a way to bundle a node server with it, I could absolutely switch to it.
In fact, I've played with the idea of providing an app that only sits in your menubar and runs the server, and opening the app just opens a tab in your browser. But most users don't care as much about all this as we think and would find that odd.
You're right though - if something is working well enough it probably will end up sticking. Slack just goes to show that it's probably Good Enough despite what we feel about it.