Yes, but have they been "push(ed) into widespread use ..."? That was the point Rich was trying to make, I think.
Yes, but have they been "push(ed) into widespread use ..."? That was the point Rich was trying to make, I think.
There have been OSS projects 'push'ed into widespread use by the popularity of a few strong personalities and herd mentality, but have questionable design. As someone with a long history of Perl, I'd lump the entire Perl language and ecosystem into that category, along with CGI and FastCGI which existed far longer than they should have before someone put their foot down and made a better open-source application interface.
Developer adoption is by no means a process by which 'he who has the most money wins', there's plenty of examples of big failures to thrust commercial designs into the public space, and there are plenty examples of shitty OSS designs getting uptake, I'm sure if you ask Linus, he could go on a long rant.
As I mentioned with Carmack's mini-GL/MCD model, new forks often get traction if they solve very real customer problems. In Carmack's case, he was developing on NeXT Hardware, for PCs, and PC consumer cards didn't run OpenGL, but often ran either DirectX or a proprietary driver API. If you are in the video game market, multiplatform portability is a given, so forking OpenGL to contain only the high performance subset for games that could run on consumer hardware was so obvious in retrospect, and solved a real program for game developers, who quickly latched onto it, and for 2nd and 3rd tier 3D accelerator vendors who couldn't get devs to use their proprietary API but could benefit from the easy to implement mini-GL.
I have no clue why they want to fork or subset libc, but before dismissing it out of hand, maybe there's a real compelling reason for it, and if there isn't, it'll have as much shelf life as proprietary Unix forks.
But using ad hominem critique in absence of a concrete proposal seems out of place to me.
Also, rather than guilt by association (Android et al, which was done under different circumstances compared with the hundreds of other libraries Google has released), why not actually hear out the concrete proposal and then criticize it?
Saying no one in category X can ever build anything good is just illogical.
And also great examples of software developers lying about their intentions early on to silence criticism of their design and the subsequent ramifications of adopting their solutions.
Multiply that by 100 when comparing Google's influence with Redhat's.
If Google wants to develop their own libc, they can. I'm f they want to make it open source, they can. There's nothing about doing those things that necessitates doing so as part of the LLVM project.