Recyclability fundamentally does not matter. If we eventually run out of aluminium or cobalt or whatever else, we can use landfills as mineral mines when that becomes economically viable.
What we really need to care about right now is CO2 emissions; in that respect, smartphones represent exceptionally good value. Including the energy used to charge it, an iPhone Xs results in 70kg of CO2 emissions over its lifespan. The average American produces 16,500kg of CO2 per year.
A smartphone feels like it should be really bad for the environment, because it's expensive and shiny and new. It actually does less damage to the environment than half a tank of gasoline or a few meaty meals. Turning down your thermostat by 2 degrees feels insignificant, but it could save as much as 1,000kg of CO2 per year.
https://www.apple.com/environment/pdf/products/iphone/iPhone...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_carbon_di...
Is economics really the primary obstacle standing in the way of "mining" landfills? I've never been to one, but just trying to imagine it, I'd would be a hell of a lot more worried about diseases, toxins, and all the other awful stuff that ends up in landfills one way or another and that would stand in the way of separating the materials you want effectively/efficiently/cleanly/etc... the economics seem like the last concern.
Now consider the sheer volume of trash — paper, plastic, foil, fumes, food, etc. — many individuals and organisations throw out every day. It essentially defies comprehension, but it's a lot. So much that's we've created an incredible reverse supply-chain to get it all out of sight and out of mind as quickly as possible, with the result that we rarely stop to think just how much crap we're all generating.
Set against this, people throwing out a tiny electronic item, even an item containing some nasty toxic stuff inside it, is a very small problem. Smartphones are novel and make for a high-profile target, but the real problem is the more mundane avalanche of detritus that accompanies modern civilisation.
It's a very large problem. In the 2017 fiscal year, Apple sold 216.76 million iPhones. Now factor in all the other manufacturers, and all the other years. Remember each one usually comes with a charging plug, a cable, some sort of earbuds, excessive showy packaging...
>At present, approx. 4–5% of world production of gold, silver and copper, as well as even up to 20% of world production of palladium and cobalt, are currently used for their production
https://www.degruyter.com/downloadpdf/j/gospo.2016.32.issue-...
That is in regards to smartphones in 2013, it's almost certainly higher now. In a random smarphone you are likely to find most, if not all, of the following: opper, nickel, silver, gold, platinum group metals, cobalt, lithium, lead, tin, zinc, rare earth metals, gallium, indium, iron, chromium, niobium, tantalum, titanium.
I've been thinking about electroinc waste a lot lately and I'm starting to think it is the reason why the universe is so quiet. Species don't destroy themselves in wars, I think they have development cycles similar to us where in a century or two they burn through a massive amount of their resources. They burn fossil fuels and negatively change their environment, they create plastics and negatively change their environments, they largely deplete the elements they require to make advanced technologies and end up with landfills full of personal electronic deices before they reach a point where they are mining asteroids and starting interstellar travel to continue to have adequate resources for general construction and manufacturing of technology.
If the other top two vendors would just achieve the same, we’d be in a much more comfortable position.