Something about this predicate seems suspect. I can understand the reasoning, but it seems like we’re mixing two separate domains of probability to arrive at the conclusion, much like the common wrong answer to the Monty Hall problem.
Something about this predicate seems suspect. I can understand the reasoning, but it seems like we’re mixing two separate domains of probability to arrive at the conclusion, much like the common wrong answer to the Monty Hall problem.
edit: it only works for German tanks because you can reasonably assume that the Germans aren't warehousing significantly more tanks than you've seen.
Seems like a silly guess. Plus bad climate and famines and wars can stop it much earlier than those 10 billion.
> When is an area overpopulated? When its population can't be maintained without rapidly depleting nonrenewable resources (or converting renewable resources into nonrenewable ones) and without degrading the capacity of the environment to support the population. In short, if the long-term carrying capacity of an area is clearly being degraded by its current human occupants, that area is overpopulated.
I agree with you that it is questionable set of assumptions, though I think when considering some of issues humanity is facing in the realm of climate change and water shortages, it's not an entirely untenable hypothesis.