Hacker News Reader

Comment by friendly_chap | Hacker News Reader

Not necessarily. Andrew Feldmar, a prominent psychologist I held in high regard advises to do exactly that: if you feel bad already, might as well take more.

View on HN

I try to keep my comments civil on here, but that's horrible fucking advice. The best thing you can do is try and relax and calm down, taking more of a drug you're having a bad experience with is the opposite of what anyone should do ever.

There is wisdom in it. Some drugs have a kind of scuzzy zone somewhere between a mild dose and next level dose. If you're taking a drug that perforce requires you to "let go", it may help take enough that you lose agency to resist.

Yeah, unfortunately the people in this thread do not have experience with this stuff and just reply based on their gut feeling.

That middle zone you describe where you are stuck between the two worlds are probably the worst.

Actually I have experience with lsd, mushrooms and some other hallucinogens. I've gotten really high on them. I've talked about it in my comments here before. I still believe it's bad advice especially for inexperienced users.

Fair enough, I do agree it's a dangerous game, I just don't agree that it's a completely stupid point.

Too much alcohol, so take more? Too much ibuprofen, so take more? If you’re poisoned by something, you don’t take more.

It's not a poisoning. It's a mental state.

I don't know who Andrew Feldmar is, but he is one incredibly stupid psychologist, likely one of the dumbest in the world if not the dumbest if what you say is true.

And what is your reasoning behind that? People who take psychedelics are very familiar with the concept of not breaking through and being stuck in a limbo state between where your ego still has a chance to fight.

Also please note this we are talking about a world renowned expert in LSD psychotherapy, who has 5 decades of experience in the matter. How many trips did you guide?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrew_Feldm%C3%A1r

Yeah, worked wonders in this case. Amazingly great outcome. Good thing he followed Feldman's instructions. Now he's guaranteed a trip to jail or maybe even the cemetery. Yeah Feldman is a genius, you're right. I'm sure the people this guy put in the hospital would agree too. Really he probably still didn't take enough. Another ten to a hundred doses would probably have been even better.

thats fucking stupid

Well, I do trust the experience of psychologists, or at least the ones familiar with LSD. I personally know some who have assisted hundreds/thousands of people during their trip.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com