This is a cool project that shows how far we've come. The Bitcoin network (wasteful or not) is currently capable of calculating 74.5 exahashes per second. You would need 10x74.5x10^18 Apollo Guidance Computers for that, you would probably need to build the equivalent of the Death Star to fit them all in the same place.
[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/AskScienceDiscussion/comments/9fax9...
Computing only gets you so far. The AGC was able to be so slow and still get the job done because what it needed to do was not "hard": it calculated orbital equations and monitored sensors. It didn't use AI, it didn't need to hash anything, it didn't work with databases or networks, it didn't render graphics in 3D 4K - all of these, we expect from modern phones.
If we want to advance space travel, the problem is not with computing. The problem is with chemistry (mostly), physics (to a lesser degree), and politics (let's be real, this is 99% of the battle).
The real tragedy of the cryptocurrency gold rush is that by providing a profit motive it decimated these kinds of collaborative computing projects.
I think the ecoin concept by itself is a step forward for the progress of humanity, and without mining, the blockchain needs a lot less resources. How would you fairly distribute ecoins if mining is excised? No idea.
Without mining, you would have an even bigger problem than distributing coins, which is making the system secure.
People are working on solutions to that (I have no idea if they will prove fruitful).
Essentially a blockchain is a database of time and energy booked to a contrived measurable $particularActivity. This activity correlates to some past opportunity cost expense (and presumably a counterpart defensive loss aversion behavior expected in the future) on the part of the person burning time and resources to support that activity. A kind of rube goldberg electricity meter with a public log, that functions as a record of someone's ante in a super simple long running casino game.
The more you spend on/invest in this activity, the less inclined you are to forfeit your recorded proof of doing it for less than whatever you consider a fair return on that sunk cost.
This mechanism is fairly universal and applies to everything from hobbies to friendships to careers. What bitcoin (any blockchain really) does is just strip the commitment-payoff mechanic present in almost all human endeavors down to a cartoonishly simplified model and tie a bunch of charts and metrics to it, and use these to collectively goose our animal chase instincts into overdrive.
I can argue that every form of money is fictional, it's only in the minds of people, it's a social construct. In fact, I can go further and say that there is absolutely nothing "physical" in this world, what is physical? just some sensations you're perceiving in your brain? Your brain is making up all the meaning.
There's another (weak) argument: somehow, building all that crazy tech and going to the moon is more important than taking care of humans who're suffering here on Earth. Why is going to the moon more productive?? who benefited from it?
I suspect this is just an intellectual circle jerk.
Compute? No. Energy? Yes, because today energy comes at the expense of environment which is running thin on the ground.
> I suspect this is just an intellectual circle jerk.
Come on, was that really necessary?
Someone just as judgemental could criticize HNers for all the energy they waste using high powered devices to sit on HN. Or air conditioning their entire house when they could simply sweat a little bit or use a fan in the one room they are in. Or driving to the movies when they could twiddle their thumbs at home for entertainment.
This is why it seems like such a belabored circlejerk.
Of course there is an ecosystem around regular money. There's no way it costs 1,000 times as much per dollar as printing the money, and, the major, universal complaint about bitcoin has been that it doesn't provide an alternative to all of the additional functions of the conventional banking system, so your point seems doubly void to me.
How can you consider my point "void" if it does provide some of the functions?
I can't understand how you can acknowledge the "ecosystem around regular money" and ignore it in the very next sentence and resort to your narrative of "1000 times the cost of printing a dollar", lol!
And you complain about hand-waving? italicizing "doesn't" isn't really a way to convince someone about what's missing.
And I don't understand what you don't understand about the factor of a thousand difference. Do you think that less than $100 in energy is dissipated in order to produce $100 worth of bitcoin, or do you think that the regular financial system costs more than a few pennies to produce and maintain $100? It's true that the cost of printing a $100 bill does not cover all of the functions of the banking system, but it's also true that dollars don't even have to be printed to be used, and those which exist only as ledger entries are far cheaper. So I think 0.1% is more like an upper bound than a lower one.
If it was so easy and cheap to print a 100$, why isn't everyone doing it? Obviously, it's not easy or cheap to do, and it's also illegal.
The US govt enforces the legality. So, you should factor in the cost of running the US govt and the cost of enforcing the law through the judicial system.
Suppose the US military disappeared overnight, what do you think will happen to the value of the dollar? you most certainly should factor in the cost of running the US army as well.
And then the banking ecosystem itself in the US, which is well over 10 trillion $ as of now.
The bitcoin ecosystem rolls all of these features into a single concise, self-policed network. I'd much rather have a permission-less SoV that is not controlled/backed by a nation state or a set of corporations (like Libra).
'perl4ever' should've tipped me off, I never learn :(. I don't think I have anymore time to argue with you.
I don't use perl any more - I discovered the joy of Visual Basic. :)
Anyway, see my other comment about the Federal Reserve. It's not that there are no other costs to maintaining dollars as a currency besides printing the paper money, it's that I think the printing costs obviously dwarf the rest.
Other way around.
Bitcoin is valued according to the market.
Mining is rewarded two ways: The inflationary (and reducing) coinbase reward for coin issuance, and transaction (txn) fees. The value of mining a block depends on these two factors, which both depend on the price of Bitcoin.
So long as the marginal cost of increasing hash rate is lower than the marginal gain of Bitcoins mined, hash rate will increase. When hash rates increase, mining difficulty is adjusted by the network to keep average block times near a 10 minute target.
With these costs and rewards, Bitcoin mining costs will reach an equilibrium near the value of mined Bitcoins, with two caveats:
* Risk from price variability and capital investment. Mining infrastructure takes time to deploy, so there is considerable lag between price and mining costs. And capital expenditures have opportunity costs, so deployed resources will reliably reflect predicted returns less these opportunity costs.
* Profit. The mining market will not mine Bitcoins for no profit (excepting brief periods, potentially) as there is no point to do so.
> it's a thousand times more expensive than conventional money
This is a comparison based on transactions, but why is that a suitable comparison? Money is both a medium of exchange and a store of value.
It's also absurd to consider that the costs of the US dollar are in printing alone; the value of US currency is underpinned by the entire US government. If they US did not have a powerful military, trade agreements reflecting that military, taxes that must be paid in dollars, etc., then dollars would not have the value they do.
The global monetary system - banks, sovereign nations, etc. - is extraordinarily expensive. But Bitcoin is a global currency, so this is the suitable comparison, even if it is very young and tremendously inflationary at the moment.
The only costs that are reasonable and appropriate to include, it seems to me, in an apples-to-apples comparison, are the costs of actually creating the money and regulating the supply.
So, ok, over and above the negligible amount to create money, it's plausible to include the cost of the Federal Reserve system, since that is what keeps the money supply stable, analogous to the mining algorithm.
The M2 money supply (a bit arbitrary, but for this comparison it's somewhat generous to the opposing view and anyway, I guess they don't publish M3 any more) is something like $14.5 trillion. The cost of the Federal Reserve is something like $5 billion[1] So the "maintenance" cost for a dollar is something like 3 cents every hundred years. To me, that seems de minimus and it also seems a person with some common sense would expect that without doing an analysis.
If you want to be obstinate about this, I suspect you will argue that bitcoin as it currently exists provides the facility to do transactions which I am not including the cost of with dollars, and my response is that the throughput of bitcoin is negligible and therefore not appropriate to equate with the capacity of the real financial system.
[1]https://www.federalreserve.gov/publications/2017-ar-federal-...
A current bitcoin transaction is equivalent to about 500kwh, which is about as much as a residential customer in the US uses in about two weeks. Or as a twitter user put it, "bitcoin is like leaving your car running over night to solve sudokus that you can trade for heroin."
And even though there is no current shortage of compute, opportunity cost still exists. Those units of compute or energy could be put to use that is a little more sensible.
We could be using the compute equivalent of the nation of Colombia to collectively simulate cancer drug molecules, or provide free resources to startups in the third world or just about anything that is more difficult than sending money from A to B, which we figured out how to do with much less resources decades ago. I think even buying a carrier pigeon might be more energy efficient (and possibly less prone to hacking) than cryptocurrency.
Get off HN and do it! what's stopping you??
> which we figured out how to do with much less resources decades ago. I think even buying a carrier pigeon might be more energy efficient (and possibly less prone to hacking) than cryptocurrency.
Sorry, you don't understand Bitcoin, you should do some research before making such shallow, reductionist arguments.
"Stone is better, why do you need metal? it's so much work to make metal implements"
"We have horses, why do you need cars that pollute the air??"
"Why do you need a smart phone, I have a desktop computer to do all that"
"Why do you need the internet?, we've already figured out how to send messages to each other via mail"
Stop acting like this is a zero sum game.
Also funny is the implication that the astronauts would have had to be careful of malware in addition to the occasional unaccounted for floating bolt.
A Waterdhavian gold dragon is a fictional possession (though, in concept, tangible).
A Bitcoin is intangible, but nonfictional.
This isn't an honest conversation though, because people are getting overly defensive about BTC.
Person A saying "this thing is totally a waste" and Person B responding "actually, no it's not, for these reasons" is not an example of Person B being "overly defensive". Especially when B provides rationalizations of their position and A does not.
And in no context I've ever seen does "fictional" mean "intangible". Even if it did, this would not be one of those times, as the context of the OC clearly indicates being dismissive of the currency as a whole, not just pointing out that it is intangible.
The original comment is obviously not using "fictional" to mean "intangible", as it is dismissive.
Since you used the word "fictional" as a continuation of the original usage without clarification at the time, one must assume, given the context, that you meant the same thing. Anything else would not be reasonable in context.
But again, nobody outside of this very discussion has ever used "fictional" when they really mean "intangible". "Imaginary" maybe, but not "fictional". I think we both know that this was a post-facto rationalization of your own unnecessarily dismissive comment.
I do appreciate you proving just how defensive Bitcoin people are, that is nice.
> If they're not fictional, show me a Bitcoin.
p.s. I'm not a Bitcoin person.
A TF2 hat, like other digital collectibles, is a nonfictional intangible object (which happens to represent a tangible object in the fiction), not an intangible fictional object.
For example, I don't know if you own any old jewelry with diamonds in it, but if you do, you can probably assume that it is worth less than you paid for it, given that diamonds can now be artificially produced with clarity / hardness / etc that parallels "natural" diamonds, and a big part of a diamond's price has historically been it's relative scarcity in nature.
It's just such a perfect metaphor for how we acquired enormous power but only used it for {insert your favorite rant subject}.