This comment is exactly why I say that.
> What you're proposing amounts to the total abandonment of all the principles that have governed amateur radio for over a century.
And this is a bad thing, somehow? In the past century, things have changed so much. For some reason, every HAM implies that encrypted communications means encrypted chatting. No one who wants encrypted comms (who I know) wants to use it for chatting, we want to use it for control mechanisms.
Quit being anti-hacker.