In some countries you have to show that you've attempted to hire locally before importing labour from abroad. I almost wonder if that's what's going on in some of these cases.
Yeah. If there is one thing I've observed over the years is that systems usually function as the design goal intended. So if you think the system is broken because the behavior is odd then there is a high chance you just misunderstood the design goal.
AFAIK You have to advertise the position with the prevailing wage for the region and the position. And you have to keep a copy of every resume received for legal reasons.
Quite possibly? As part of PERM I've had to advertise in a local newspaper for a minimum amount of time, and be ready justify rejecting each applicant. You can imagine how many applicants there were though...