Buying lattes is not keeping you from being rich
nytimes.com
nytimes.com
Tracking every transaction (with e.g. gnucash), minimizing expenses, setting a maximum liquid and investing everything above that on a month per month basis is the basics.
But this silly book suggests budgeting (and spending these budgets whether needed or not), which is not how to do personal finances.
Be frugal, track everything, and invest. That's the gist of it. Being frugal starts with _not_ buying the book.
Tracking means looking back, and doing the accounting.
[With zero data backup] most do neither; some track; but those who track with a budget have better outcomes.
Then one gets into relationships, and finding that harmonious blending of skill/maturity with these concepts.
I just don't spend anything, and the Hausdrachen[1] manages all the YNAB data
I do agree. But here's one sentence from that article:
>That would leave 20 to 35 percent to spend guilt-free.
The quality of their "budgeting" is self-explanatory.
Most people won’t come to the conclusion to invest $4 a day in an index, but might instead buy a nice espresso machine to make the drink at home because they know exactly when the payoff date is. A successful person probably won’t stop drinking lattes, but they’ll change their habits, which is often very hard in practice.
Being successful in finances is about being disciplined, not necessarily about living a spartan lifestyle. Often times that means trading comfort and convenience for something else (money) and I’d wager that mental trade is a winnowing fork for people who will have very different life outcomes.
Woman: Do you drink beer?
Man: Yes
Woman: How many beers a day?
Man: Usually about 3
Woman: How much do you pay per beer?
Man: $5.00, including tip
Woman: And how long have you been drinking?
Man: About 20 years, I suppose.
Woman: So a beer costs $5 and you have 3 beers a day, which puts your spending each month at $450, or $5400 annually. Not accounting for inflation, you have spent $108,000 in the last 20 years! That money could've been put into an investment account and, after accounting for compound interest for the past 20 years, you would now have enough money to buy a Ferrari.
Man: Do you drink beer?
Woman: No
Man: Where’s your Ferrari?
Also it's never a good idea to assume that something that is not important to you personally (or that you can forgo) is the same to someone else. This argument even comes up with respect to the number of hours someone works. Some people love to push this idea that 'you have to relax and take time off' as if everyone feels the same way and does not like to work like a 'workaholic'.
But it's pretty reasonable to think about routine or automated purchases that are just habits.
Real life is more complex.
While buying lattes might not keep someone from being rich (as an expense), buying frivolous things, using too much credit (they can't back) and not investing their money on things with a ROI (not just in actual investments: also in self-education, better work tools, and so on) can and does keep many people from getting richer (where richer != rich).
- David Bach evangelized it in the mid-2000's.
- Ramit was using those lines at least back in 2010 "I'll show you how to earn more, too. Let others worry about saving $3 on lattes. I hope you'll be earning hundreds more -- or more -- each month." is a line from one of his emails.
- Whoever is creating Suze Orman content keeps using it: https://twitter.com/CNBC/status/1137464817738952704
I've seen it used as a headline for at least two decades (first time on some business school poster at UTexas), a bit after when starbucks late 90's expansion. Arguably since then coffee shops have had more 'business value' for some as laptop ownership became more common.
Saving 1M for retirement by 65 is within the reach of many Americans.
For the worst case scenario, the median wage for a worker with no high school diploma is 30k. Putting away 5k per year in a Roth IRA, every year, until age 65 would leave them with ~1.1M, assuming a 6% (1.1% lower than historical) return. While this is a high savings rate -- ~15%, it is not impossible to hit in most places. This is ignoring catch up contributions, taxes, employer match, Social Security (rip) etc, but it's safe to say this is totally doable in most locales.
Given that the median salary for someone with a college degree is about ~65k, it is well within the grasp of median Americans to save 1M+ for retirement.
However, things like predatory lending, bullshit money gurus, and plain old ignorance stop most Americans from realizing this dream. It's possible, but there is simply no substitute for compounding growth.
Time is the most important factor. Saving a percentage of income, invested for growth, executed over decades is a well-proven scheme.
Finanacial education is a rare and precious resource.
In my opinion, every financial literacy book/seminar/podcast should be renamed to "Shut up and wait" by law.
I was thinking we just have only this present moment only and we do not know what will happen in future.
We should sure prepare for future but enjoy the every moment. Buy latte if you need it and you want to enjoy that moment than sure buy it. You do not know you will be able to spend that $5 again or not or enjoy that again.
Well guess what? Our default condition as human beings born into the world is deprivation, uncertainty, insecurity and suffering. If everyone of the past used the "live in the moment" argument to discount saving or having children, we'd never see society advance.
That latte might be nothing, it might be the million dollar opportunity.
It might be family or friends, too.
That aside, this book apparently says pretty much the same thing as every other popular book on the subject.
It's a mindset. Visit Bogleheads.org, where scads of people will explain first-hand how they lived below their means (for a few decades), invested for growth, and now have prospered.
It's a proven methodology. It absolutely works. And yes, a daily latte is not going to be on the must-have list for most of the proven accumulators.
Write a self-help book telling people they can get in the path of being rich in 6 weeks
then it's BS.