"The episode of The Big Bang Theory that contained the discussion about 73, was actually the 73rd of the series!"
There are two conjectures here. The first is that 73 is the only number that matches these criteria. The second (as stated by Sheldon) is that meeting the criteria make a number "the best number". The second conjecture... let's just call that "unproven".
I would call that second one a definition, not a conjecture. "Best" is an arbitrary value judgment. You can't prove what is or isn't best because it is not an objective question.
But yes, it is an open question.
My pet peeve with 73 being "best" number is that a lot of these properties relies on representing this number in decimal (or binary in case of Sheldon-Norris number). I'd like properties that were independent of base selected to represent the number.
That's fair enough, but binary is the lowest base anyone can use...