I used html for years. Once my email volume reached a certain point, I went back to plain text because I can read it and respond to it much faster.
I used html for years. Once my email volume reached a certain point, I went back to plain text because I can read it and respond to it much faster.
images loading..2%
images loading..15%
images loading..29%
images loading..42%
images loading..58%
images loading..74%
images loading..89%
images loading..100%
____________________________________
| |
| O O |
| O |
| \_/ |
| MY LOGO |
| My catchphrase |
| |
| |
| |
|------------------------------------|
| |
| Hi josho! |
| |
| This is why it's slower to read! |
| |
|____________________________________|Clients load images asynchronously, and no personal email is sent with a logo and catchphrase header. I've never seen that in my entire life and I've been using email with a lot of people, for a long time.
Formatting is an issue however, and the addition of formatting to email can be useful and add to the conversation.
To take the hn example again, the text portion of your comment is broken on mobile because hn doesn't support proper formatting. This has made your comment harder to read.
>Clients load images asynchronously
Many clients actually don't load images by default for privacy reasons requiring another click.
Even if not one reasonably assumes that the image may be relevant and waits for it to load. Half the planet also has a pretty slow connection.
>To take the hn example again, the text portion of your comment is broken on mobile
You see the whole thing either turn your phone sideways or scroll sideways.
the 1% that isn't psychological is how much faster _everything_ is when dealing with a plaintext client (neomutt in my case). "Power Users" use the keyboard to navigate gmail. Normal (neo)mutt users use those _all_ the time and they're faster because there's so much less for the computer to do with each keystroke.
I find that a very large percentage of the html email I receive is actually hurting readability by way of formatting.
On top of that, a sizable percentage who send html email fail to take accessibility into account and leave out important elements like alt tags.
This is exactly right. In principle, html is just as convenient, but in practice it regularly fails. Something I really hate is a message with big images that add nothing. If I have to scan a message to figure out what's being said, there's a high probability I will leave it for later, which means it never gets read at all.
With top posting, in order to read a mail - especially one that is a few levels deep in a thread - becomes an exercise in jumping back and forth, trying to find context and make sense of who replies to what, finding relevant sentences (often hidden in a mess of signatures).
With bottom posting and proper curated quoting, context is a glance away, and it's easy to see who said what in reply to what.
I'm sure this would be possible with HTML mails as well, but I've never seen it happen. It's all just a mess of hard to find information in the least sensible order imaginable.
Q: Why is top-posting such a bad thing?
A: Top-posting.
Q: What is the most annoying thing in email?
It is not, so long as you first quote the relevant part you are replying to.
At some point you can also trim the tail as you see fit (I don't find it necessary because my mail client does a good enogh job at hiding that part unless I click on a "show wverything" button.
> 2019-07-24 10:50 earthboundkid wrote:
> Q: Why is top-posting such a bad thing?
>> 2019-07-23 23:55 someonelse wrote:
>> A: Top-posting.
>>> 2019-07-23 22:00 first guy wrote:
>>> Q: What is the most annoying thing in email?
Technically it appears that I'm advocating for a combination of inline and top posting. Quoting the relevant wikipedia part:
> The interleaved reply style can also be combined with top-posting: selected points are quoted and replied to, as above, and then a full copy of the original message is appended.
Not doing top posting literally has confused recipients of my mails (almost all instances).
So now I'm a top poster as well: i use emails to communicate, not to confuse.
The reason why is because many clients fold emails that have redundant text in them -- and may hide bottom or interleaved posts within the fold.
Modern clients assume the "Outlook style" -- HTML formatted email, top posting. If you want your message to be read, use this style.
Indeed, it would be nice if the netizens of the world would wake up to this. Sadly, I think it's unlikely to improve any time soon and so I'll stick to top posting and threading in the email client.