So personal recommandations should be disclosed ? That kinda goes against the point of trying to have an open discussion about a potential appliant. And what would the recourse be anyways ?
What good would a talk do, since admittedly it's a person and not a work problem ? Do any good come out of people explaining how they despise your attitude, especially with high stakes, where no response will ever bring closure ?
Yes, btw I hope the publisher has more insight than the reader and does a background check.
Edit : though I agree that the team should've hold a discussion, as sterile as it probably would've been, for it's own reputation.