I also have to say that every time they bashed us, we took it as constructive feedback and acted upon that in a really positive way. Now we have a startup with better product-market-fit.
They do mention that part of their algorithm is if you're matched against someone higher and get upvoted over them, you'll receive more points. So if you're the higher rank and getting downvoted compared to someone lower, you probably lose more points.
On top of that, they are giving away money. Why shouldn't they get to choose who they give it to? Sure they could be a little more transparent if they are really manipulating that much.
At the end of the day, just vote with your feet.