Atlantic.net blew minds of colo market when it provided API'able PDUs in early 2000s. Not the "SSH via this place into the APC with your username and a password see the status and trigger a power cycle" but "Send this payload to the following end point". PXE boot without manual tweaks is still basically non-existent in the colo space. I could continue with these examples but it should be enough.
That's the reason why AWS/GC/Azure win, not because they are centralized.
The minuses for AWS/GC/Azure is that no matter how big you are, unless you are Netflix or Snapchat you are still a very small customer which means that AWS/GC/Azure organization cares less about your happiness than Comcast does about the happiness of a random cable TV customer spending $180 a month on a triple play.
That truism is often repeated, despite the fact that it contradicts Netflix's own strategy[1]:
> We would prefer to be an insignificant customer in a giant cloud.
This means that its problems are addressed first regardless of what kind of general rules the "cloud" has. One can see it everywhere -- the larger and the bigger the customer the more important it is.
Yes, out of the box tooling is part of the "centralized" platform. In a decentralized world you stack some adhoc open-source tools and web dashboards atop your hand-rolled infrastructure. This is more work than a centralized solution that provides the metal and everything else you could possibly need (and everything you will never need) as a single centralized package.
> PXE boot without manual tweaks is still basically non-existent in the colo space. I could continue with these examples but it should be enough.
Those examples support my position.
> That's the reason why AWS/GC/Azure win, not because they are centralized.
They could not do this without being centralized, that's precisely the point.
Servint, Erols, DedicatedNow, DigitalNation, etc started before Amazon. So did EV1 or Choopa. They simply played a game of hardware rather than software tooling. As the hardware became more and more commoditized the software became more and more important. C/Panel and Plesk did not cut it. That's why Amazon/Google/Azure won.