IIRC the reason is that people would regularly screw up __cmp__ (despite the cmp built-in being available), it’s harder to fuck up simple boolean results that the any-integer-coerced-to-3-state of cmp.
Python 3 also removed the “everything is comparable” misfeature of P2, providing way lower incentive to implement ordering: if your type is not orderable, a user knows to go with key functions.