You just expelled every family with a mortgage or a car payment or a student loan from the middle class. You also radically redefined the concept of "middle".
On a side note, I think all the above are excellent ways of debt.
Right now you can get a mortgage for under 4%. Mortgages typically do not compound interest. So it makes more sense to dump your savings into one of many savings that pay a similar interest rate or higher & do compound interest.
Many car dealers have 0% interest if you want to buy your car & not lease.
Of course any education debt that gets you a salary much higher than the debt makes sense as well.