Rich people have gardens. Poor people liver crammed together in city slums.
...is one story you can tell. These things are hopelessly intertwined with confounding factors, and I never pay attention to them. The ones interesting enough to go viral and show up in my feed are of course extra suspicious.
Why not? Maybe people who feel well are more likely to care about their environment, and e.g. organize protests when someone wants to remove trees from their neighborhood. Meanwhile, depressed people will watch their environment deteriorate, and do nothing about it.
(I am not saying this is how it is, just proposing a possible causal mechanism.)
A possible common-cause explanation could be that some places are designed "for people to feel happy", and those contain trees, but also other things (parks? accessible sidewalk? or perhaps those are simply places where many nice people live?) which make people happy.
wealthy people -> wealthy community
| |
v v
good health treesTaken together those are likely to capture socio-economic status in all but a few edge cases. With a very large study size, and a huge result (30% difference) it's unlikely that it can be explained by socioeconomic status.
The study discusses this by the way.
Socio-economic status is notoriously difficult to control for.
If you disagree with the studies methodology fine, but I'm satisfied that authors have done their due diligence with respect to socio-economic status.