For something to be called a joke it should require at least some creativity. Check out Don Rickles and Triumph the Insult Comic Dog for good examples of what an insult joke is. Calling someone an old fart just isn't funny. It's a worn out insult.
For something to be called a joke it should simply be intended as a joke. My goodness, do we really need to overanalyze everything? Just relax.
This is HN. A certain segment of the community here has a tendency towards over analyzing things. They can’t help it.
I come to this site primarily because I like to analyze things. And no, an attempted joke is not necessarily a joke.
You must be really fun at parties.
The parties you go to must be really fun to be at.
Would you please stop feeding this flamewar? It's off topic regardless of how provocative the title was.
It’s in the article on a different site for ducks sake. Or do you expect every submission to be reviewed and fixed according to your joke sensitivity standards?
Ok, but are you raising or lowering the signal/noise ratio by continuing to post like this here? Clearly lowering, therefore please don't.