>My first paper (and, in fact, the first paper) on public key cryptography was submitted in 1974 and initially rejected by an unknown "cryptography expert" because it was "...not in the main stream of present cryptography thinking...."
>My first paper (and, in fact, the first paper) on public key cryptography was submitted in 1974 and initially rejected by an unknown "cryptography expert" because it was "...not in the main stream of present cryptography thinking...."
Is there any proof peer review has
increased scientific productivity?
It is relatively new
According to [1] "The council minutes of 1 March 1665 made provisions for the tract to be revised by members of the council of the Royal Society, providing the framework for peer review to eventually develop, becoming fully systematic as a process by the 1830s."Peer review is a relatively new procedure in the same way that California is a relatively new state :-p
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philosophical_Transactions_of_...
Most revolutionary scientific discoveries were made without it.
If you name a famous publication prior to 1900, it almost certainly was published without peer review.
I married into the field, didn’t work in it, but that’s what I’ve observed from the side.
A system with an "editorial teaming willing to delegate when necessary" simply becomes the current system as the editorial team is willing and able to delegate, and it's neccessary pretty much all the time because of resource constraints - because being an editor generally also is an unpaid volunteer position done in addition to your normal work in academia.