Ok let me phrase it differently. If you have some library function that does some IO (for example) and you want to make it as useful as possible, would you declare it async or not? If you make it blocking, then you'd ruin any opportunity to have it called from async functions (because they don't want to be blocked). Therefore, you'd make it async. So that means that all IO library routines will become async, and possibly a lot of others too. Wouldn't it make more sense to have async be the default?