Hacker News Reader

Comment by vageli | Hacker News Reader

> well, that and moving large sums of money isn't quite as easy as say changing email providers

In what ways? If you close your account they need to give you all of your money at the time of closure.

Having worked at a bank, I can tell you that they are scared by how mobile millennials are with their money. They will literally follow the interest rates. With most millennials using credit and not debit/ach, it becomes even easier to move to a new banking provider.

View on HN

thanks for your reply, i'm truly interested in this as i have money stuck in a low interest checking account that i want to move to Simple. i'm in the US.

if i have $50K in a checking account they're obligated to write me a check (?) for $50K if i tell them i want to close my account?

if that's correct, does the amount matter? when do AML/KYC laws kick in? will these online focused banks accept new accounts funded with checks over $10K?

Just do a ACH balance transfer, move your bills, then close the account. No need to be driving a paper check around.

If you'll think billing problems will occur, break the transfer into two chunks and keep both accounts open for two months or so until satisfied.

For large amounts of money, I think the best way is to open your new account, wire transfer (not ACH or check) the money to your new account, confirm that the funds are received, then close the old account. This will likely cost ~$25 depending on your old bank but it avoids the hold periods you'll otherwise get with a check (even a cashier's check) or ACH transfer, as well as issues with moving physical cash.

You don't need to worry about AML/KYC laws, those are the bank's problem. In fact, using smaller transfers to avoid hitting the $10k threshold is illegal.

The only significance of $10,000 is that it’s the amount that triggers reporting. Such transactions aren’t illegal or even suspicious. They’ll write you a check for the full amount and the other bank will accept it. There might be a hold on the funds for several days until the check clears. As another commenter mentions, you can open the new account first and do an electronic transfer which will make the funds available sooner.

depending on your original account, if it has a minimum balance to avoid fees you might want to leave the minimum balance in there and transfer the rest first. Then close the account officially and get a check for the remainder. the reason is that if you transfer it all and it goes under a minimum deposit, you could get a fee and then you are overdrawn, generating more fees and more overdraw. Generally just taking all money out of an account doesn't automatically close it.

But, closing an account does result in all of the money coming out, avoiding any potential balance issues since the deposit is refunded upon closure, in full.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com