My thoughts exactly. This post has nothing constructive to offer.
The simple truth is that CAPTCHAs are a very good initial defence to spammers. We've been trying to find a problem to replace CAPTCHAs, but we haven't been able to find one that satisfies all these properties:
1. It has to be easy for a computer to create.
2. It has to be easy for a computer to verify.
3. The problem space has to be very large to thwart precalculation attacks.
4. It has to be easy for a human to solve.
5. It has to be hard for a computer to solve.
Your math example fails #4, and the cats example fails #3.
EDIT: How do we make lists in HN markdown?