Then if you want the trust that the verification of apple gives you, you should make sure you only download software from apple.com, but the whole system is still more open and accessible by being online on websites rather than specific to a piece of software running on OSX.
I don't trust you that your website isn't spam.
I don't trust you with my credit card number.
I don't trust you that your program is well made and follows conventions.
I don't trust you that you won't install a Trojan on my machine.
I don't trust you that you won't put Adware all over.
I don't trust you that your app is bug free and won't ruin the performance on my computer.
But if Apple accepts your app into the app store, I don't have to worry about these things.