For years people used custom ROMs to block Android gps data collection and Google didn't care. Then someone added the option to send random data instead and Google filed a C&D within days.
Edit: Yes, I understand that it is annoying for the ad networks to have to register lots of wasted clicks, but that doesn't benefit me at all. It just makes my own browsing slower. I figure at least 20% of the people browsing the web would have to use the extension for it to make any difference to the ad networks, and it's probably higher than 20%. That's never going to happen.
> I figure at least 20% of the people browsing the web would have to use the extension for it to make any difference to the ad networks, and it's probably higher than 20%. That's never going to happen.
They have tried though:
https://adnauseam.io/free-adnauseam.html
So it means, they are worried about at least enough to bother.
Now, looking at my stats I just don't see as many clicks as before. So perhaps, Google just fixed their backend code to detect these clicks and moved on without triggering the Streisand Effect by fighting against this project publicly further.
Yes it compromises on privacy compared to just plain adblock. But if it hides all ads anyway, does it matter if nobody is making money off of you? The noise that the ad-clicking introduces must mess with your ad interest profile at least a little.
Individual people opting out of tracking doesn't meaningfully attack the ad tracking infrastructure, and will always be limited to a small percentage of technically proficient users who care about privacy.
A collective approach feeds bad data into their infrastructure, making their data less meaningful for ad tracking and also helping protect the privacy of everyone.
The tracking will still be there, but the tracker will never know if you granted access or not, it would always look legit.
Unfortunately, I imagine that would be tough to pull off in practice because the problem isn't just with web browsers, it's with every piece of software that embeds telemetry SDKs.
Already happens. I don't see nearly as many clicks accumulated in AdNauseum as I used to a few years ago.
Google tried to ban the extension https://adnauseam.io/free-adnauseam.html, but they've probably been reminded about the Streisand effect and just fixed their code to check for it and ignore it.
Followup question off of GP's: if networks know to filter click-fraud out based on metrics as simple as browser version, then aren't those same metrics exploitable to avoid tracking? Firefox's resist fingerprinting setting locks the reported browser version to the latest ERS. If I have that turned on, will every ad click I make be ignored?
Keep in mind, the big goal I have with misinformation is to confuse user profiles; not to generate fake clicks or waste money -- it's to make is so that my actual data profile is either unreliable or outright ignored.
If this kind of filtering is so ubiquitous, then would it be feasible defense to get user browsers to act like bots instead of getting bots to act like users? How bot-like would I need to be before advertisers started assuming the data they collected from me was untrustworthy?
One thing that ultimately breaks through the noise isn’t what ads you see or click on, but what you actually buy. If you buy things and aren’t completely blocking every ad network, you’ll massively boost the signal. Also any real browsing routines will still be in the data, and I am assuming a lot of ad networks are informed by out of band data they purchase and things like ISP data they buy.
Ultimately the proof is in the pudding. You should experiment with various approaches and then see if you are served relevant ads, if you aren’t, you’re winning :)
FWIW I get a ton of irrelevant ads because of retargeting. I visit a lot of my customer’s websites in doing my job and they’re not usually sites I’d go to, so most of the ads I see on FB and Twitter are based on retargeting from those sites.
But at the end of the day it doesn't really change much. They're going to detect signal somewhere or another. Where they detect it, they keep the data and source locations, where they don't they update their spam ML models. Unless you start going to the illegal side of the spectrum (DDOS, widespread fraudulent ad engagement, etc) you're not even going to piss them off, really. They won't even notice you.