Hacker News Reader

Hmm.. has anyone ever been sued for adding captions? I don't see how they would.. as far as the end user is concerned, the captions are embedded into the video, are not a separate performance or a product. Not exactly analogous to audiobook vs ebook.

View on HN

Captions is exactly what's being offered though. Amazon is not providing an ebook, they're providing captions in-sync with the audiobook.

The difference between an audiobook and a video is pretty small in a significant portion of YouTube content.

The difference is that audio-books is a separate product category with its own pricing. Embedding text in a video is quite different IMHO...

If Amazon added an animation to the existing audiobook content - making it a video - and then added captions would that be OK?

As the GP said, there's quite a few youtube videos with a completely static background where the content is the speaker's words.

>If Amazon added an animation to the existing audiobook content - making it a video - and then added captions would that be OK?

AFAIK, they would have to obtain prior permission from the copyright owner before re-distributing a modified version of the copyrighted work.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com