Meanwhile, in my experience, statistical understanding and the general skills required to understand why an analysis would or would not be valid is virtually non-existent for most people. Also, the majority of parties involved have a vested interest in the story of the effectiveness of marketing being perpetuated. Data vendors and advertisers, including giants like Google and Facebook, no longer have a product if it isn't. Consulting companies and internal analytics teams do ton of work solely focused on marketing. That all goes away if people realize its a useless exercise. The companies buying the advertising, who one would think would absolutely be interested in knowing if their dollars are going to waste, are filled with people whose jobs are contingent on the idea that marketing is driving business.
I'm not convinced marketing does nothing. But I think the effect is greatly overstated. And I think its becoming less effective over time. I can't remember the last time I clicked on an advertised result on Google, or a banner ad. Perhaps they were useful at one point years ago, but I think people are increasingly learning to tune them out over time, the same way one would acclimate to a noisy environment. Coincidentally, I remember seeing a link here on HN relatively recently about how the New York Times completely dropped their targeted marketing efforts, and found that their subscription growth remained unchanged. I think that were more companies to follow suit, many would see similar results.