Cambridge: "impossible or very difficult to believe:"
Dictionary.com: "so extraordinary as to seem impossible: incredible speed. not credible; hard to believe; unbelievable: The plot of the book is incredible."
Or is dictionary.com too incredible?
And, I know I'm risking hardcore my karma here, but I see "good" used as a moral measure. I doubt that "incredible" is referring to the interviewee's moral excellence, but I could imagine that perhaps the interviews are along the lines of becoming a better person.
As long as we're quoting dictionary definitions (also from dictionary.com). We're using definition 2, here:
incredible adjective
1. beyond belief or understanding; unbelievable
2. informal marvellous; amazing
Good is definitely a judgment, but there is no reason to suppose it is a moral one. If I say a sandwich is good, it means that I like the taste not that I think it is righteous in the eyes of God. Ironically, perhaps, if I thought the sandwich was especially delicious, I might say that it is righteous. The vast majority of native English speakers would immediately understand my intended meaning rather than the literal one.
I find it somewhat incredible that I have to explain this.