What If Silicon Valley’s ‘Brilliant Jerks’ Are Just Jerks?
bloomberg.com
bloomberg.com
I know its controversial, but imagine that this was someone's really cute husky. Sure every day it would bounce about the place and make funny husky noises.
However every week, on a sunday, it would attack your child and poop on the carpet.
A normal person wouldn't shrug and say, "Hubert the husky brings a lot of value to the household, so lets just ignore this." No. You'd bollock the arrogant shit when it did wrong, and praise it when it was good.
The dirty secret of Silicon value is that actually, individuals are replaceable. What isn't replaceable is time and money. The cult of the Jerk is a defence mechanism to allow shit to continue to be shits.
repeat after me:
If they've broken the law or done something morally grey, bollock them.
I know that sounds radical and foreign, but its part of a thing called "wider society"
edit - also known as 'best practice' when writing bespoke software for industry.
In 1998, Levandowski entered the University of California, Berkeley, where he earned bachelor's and master's degrees in Industrial Engineering and Operations Research.[12] As a freshman, he launched an intranet service from his basement.[3] In 2004 he and fellow UC Berkeley engineers built an autonomous motorcycle, nicknamed Ghostrider, for the DARPA Grand Challenge.[13] The Ghostrider motorcycle competed in the DARPA Grand Challenge in 2004 and 2005 and was the only autonomous two-wheeled vehicle in the competition.[14] The motorcycle now resides in the Smithsonian National Museum of American History.[3]
I challenge the author of the article to build this:
Which to me is a fairly good question.
At the same time I can respect the good things a person achieved in his life and look down on the bad things that he did (and shouldn't have been tolerated).
I view the author's view too simplistic: ,,What if “brilliant jerks” are just plain jerks?''
It doesn't.
It doesn't have to cost much more than $20k or so. Budgets went into $x00k range for the first Darpa challenge (x < 3 or so).
Who paid for it ? DARPA. Also known as the US military.
PS when you copy and paste wikipedia you should say so.
So long as you're a "geek" its ok to be a monstrous shit?
Is that what you're arguing here?
gotcha
This is a really weird grouping. It's mixing people who have built incredibly valuable things (Rubin) with those who are famous for failing to do so (Holmes); and people who broke the law by committing fraud (which seems like an unusual use of the word "jerk") with those who have been accused of sexual misconduct.
Travis Kalanick did a lot of ethically sketchy things up to the point where he was removed from his own company.
Holmes did a lot of ethically sketchy things up to the point where the wheels came off.
Conrad did sketchy things up to the point where someone realized he wasn't actually doing what he was supposed to.
Rubin did sketchy things up to the point that Google paid him to close the door behind him.
The key commonality is that they did sketchy things, people knew they were doing sketchy things, and the entrepreneureal and tech community lionized them up to the point where doing so became embarrassing. (And seems to be continuing to do so, judging by this thread.)
Sure let’s generalize entire industry based on one nutcase. Brilliant article.
Then I wonder if I would become a jerk simply due to fatigue.
Good thing I dont have to worry about it too much :)
Go to city hall or DMV, try get something done, and you will understand how dealing with inflexible idiots feels. (note that you're not dumb because you work at city hall/DMV, but if you're not dumb you have better options and go somewhere else. So over time, these places collect idiots). When you're smarter, there's a lot of DMVs.
It's not like dealing with people a little less smart or smarter than you feels (in fact they will regularly outsmart you, you'll just outsmart them just a tad more than the other way). That's just fine, interesting, and doesn't stand in anyone's way. It's dealing with people much dumber than you that's the problem.
Here's a repeating conversation that's frustrating. The problem is smart people play chess, whereas normal people just play a move.
"I want to X" "But that's (insane|difficult|not what I'd like to do|not what I see|...), why not Y ?" "Because Y leads to Z, to A, and likely to B, which is a negative for me" "But why not C ?" "Because C leads to D, E and then again to B, which is not what I want" "But ..." (continue for another 10 minutes)
Or people that hate you because you "make them feel dumb" (which is exactly what they do to you when you have to explain everything of course, but never mind that). And you might say "why not make them feel smart". And sure, I do that. That's easy. But it takes time and energy, and I'm just not going to do that 100x every day. 10x, sure. No problem. But there's a limit.
Or people who feel like they're entitled to your intelligence. Every last problem they encounter. "Hey <drop everything and> come look at this", and then the first time you don't they immediately escalate.
Or just playing chess, then looking at "idiots" moving on the playing field. And seeing them placing themselves into impossible positions and ...
Also worse is that you see people's motivations. How, say, social workers are going to discuss a new policy to do X, and this sounds really positive and you're the only one in the room that's "but, no it isn't positive at all. Because the motivations of these guys that are involved are to ... and that will lead to ..., which is going to destroy these peoples' lives, and you KNOW this but you're suggesting the policy because your organization will once again have to expand". For example, "early detection of child abuse" by people who are paid for finding child abuse will lead to ... false accusations. And of course, once again they will find much more than their worst fear. Or helping the homeless by "providing accomodations", and you want to scream that no, they want them off the street because they think it'll increase their house's value and their ego while effectively arresting and locking up these people.
Or worse: you actually go look at the accommodations they were talking about, because you're interested. Either for those abused kids, or for those homeless. And then you know: there is no act as despicable, counterproductive and outright evil as "professionals" "helping" people.
I don't think skipping compliments equals to being a jerk. I'd look at actions, and I don't remember Linus did something nasty.
"My flippant attacks in emails have been both unprofessional and uncalled for. Especially at times when I made it personal. In my quest for a better patch, this made sense to me. I know now this was not OK and I am truly sorry.
The above is basically a long-winded way to get to the somewhat painful personal admission that hey, I need to change some of my behavior, and I want to apologize to the people that my personal behavior hurt and possibly drove away from kernel development entirely."
That’s wishful thinking. A lot of jerks will never be fired and are terrible at their job. It’s not that simple and isn’t cheap to fire someone.
IMHO the main difference is mostly that jerks with power will negatively impact more people, thus are more visible.
Also, your real job is making your manager look good to his manager, not actually the nominal job of writing reliable, stable, flexible code that you signed up for in your employment agreement.
In many organisations, usually larger ones, they're usually the first to get promoted as they spend all of their time "managing up".