Generally most hotels fail on the pitch black during the day requirement because they only have curtains (only roller shutters, aluminum foil on the window or having no window can block all light), they aren't very good at being silent (no soundproofing, room service with carts at morning, road in front without properly insulated windows, etc.) and you generally don't get an high-quality mattress and bed unless you go for an high-end hotel (with lots of useless amenities) and often the bed is not even acceptable (too small, no wood foundation, bad mattress, sheets that aren't big enough to always stay tucked in, or even sheets that can't be tucked in at all).