Definitely a bit nerve-wracking on who can see if you're using it, potentially, since you know, I'd never want people on Facebook to know I'm using a "dating app", but other than that, I actually really like the implementation here.
"Just like your 2FA phone number won't be used for anything except 2FA." - Facebook /s
Add all your friends to Secret Crush. Watch who matched you.
"Sorry buddy, I wasn't really using the thing, I just added everyone, but thanks for letting me know you like me!"
Idiots. And this is why the shared identity is a terrible idea for dating sites. You want dating profiles to be throwaway, and you want it to be hard for your friends to find your dating persona for this reason!
But of course Facebook doesn't understand the need to keep secrets from (some of) your friends.
Believe it or not, they actually have put some thought into their final product based on the beta tests conducted in smaller international markets.
You: "Sorry buddy, I wasn't really using the thing, I just added everyone, but thanks for letting me know you like me! Haha gotcha! :D"
Them: "Oh, okay... [You fuckin' weirdo. -20 rapport]"
I don't really see the epic exploit here.
Unless you and your friends only have 9 facebook friends each, you prove nothing with this bizarre hypothetical you've constructed.
I come along a few months later, and rotate all my friends through this list, and so I discover which of my friends have secret crushes on me, because I'm not using the feature like you're "supposed" to.
I feel bad for anyone secretly in love with someone like that. That's not a conversation I'd like to have.
Just say you were doing the same thing. Can atleast deny it to leave some doubt, can't really question why you added everyone to Secret Crush when they also apparently did it.
It’s not “privacy is a concern”, it’s “this thing is significantly worse for my privacy than this other thing”. Not caring about privacy because it’s “always a concern” falls to take into account that there are varying levels of privacy that services provide.
We've already seen what social media connected to advertising does to election security, do you really think its a good idea to test it on your love life?