I am actually appalled and baffled at American Express not applying case sensitivity. Like, what the actual.
So I got a shirt that said "myself@iwenttodefcon7.andalligotwas.thislousyemailaddress.com"
Not too much later, I ended up working in software validation, and I broke so many login forms with that perfectly-valid address, I lost count.
Since then, Halibut Stuff dissolved and the forwarding service is long gone. If some HN reader wanted to set up a Mailinator-like service that generates absurd-yet-RFC-compliant email addresses for such testing, I think there might be a market.
Until a few years ago it was fairly commonplace for sites to reject my perfectly valid addresses just because they had more than one period (i.e., a subdomain) or in one case, ended in the .us TLD.