I'll take algorithms over payola. At least they suggest things to me that I'd like to hear.
It's particularly concerning because there did a study that showed in different control groups of music listeners, new songs became popular just based on which ones became popular earlier.
I mean, try this trick on yourself: find a random song and listen to it 20 times. Odds are you'll like it a lot better after the first several listens than the first time.
If in addition to that all your friends happened to know and like the song, and they started advertising the artists heavily, bam! It's a hit. It's just groupthink, and we're all susceptible to it.
If that's the end result, I think we need to bring back payola.
I have no problem with Spotify's algorithms. They do a very good job with a very difficult problem.