In my country, if you earn 80%+ of your income as a contractor from a single company (with some limitations), you're labeled as dependant contractor, and special rules apply (eg: they can't just break a contract, they must give notice first, etc).
When the gov't made noises about small business tax reform people screamed bloody murder and they had to climb down. Which only shows you how pervasive this kind of 'contracting' as tax avoidance actually is.
I must admit that I don't know enough of both situations to say much.
There seems to be quite a bit of vitriol online about the rule changes in the UK though.
I do remember reading the rules when I became a contractor a few years back and thinking: Ok, so I'm inside IR35, going to use an umbrella company as it's simpler. Was told that i was a fool and contract was outside IR35. As far as I could tell, nobody meet, or indeed, could meet the substitution clause.