You’re totally right but the 2nd gen Apple Pencil can’t hold charge for very long even when not being used — so that wouldn’t work.
I use it on-and-off all day, and when I’m not using it I either toss it on the table or click it back onto the iPad, based on whichever motion is easier. I’ve never thought “ugh, I need to click it back onto the iPad to recharge”.
Sounds like you’ve got a defective battery, mine and other commenters here don’t have that issue.
Besides, doesn’t it get like almost an hour of usage after an absurdly short charge of like a minute?
Who said that?