What’s Behind the World’s Biggest Climate Victory? Capitalism
bloomberg.com
bloomberg.com
2) it isn't a completely clickbait title.
Still, is undeniable that the market forces worked against renewable energies for a lot of time, the article fails to demonstrate (it doesn't even speculate) how this adoption it's better under capitalism than in other economic frameworks. For all we can tell from the article, maybe renewable energies thrived despite capitalism.
And yet, the article provides interesting data, it's a shame it's framed as propaganda for the Markets Cult.
A society that cooks itself in its own gasses is obviously sick. Healthy societies don't charge headlong at their own destruction. It's an obvious failure of thinking, organization, and culture.
If capitalism is the organizing principle of a society, then capitalism is responsible for that society's problems. If they are small, then that is to capitalism's credit. If they are gigantic, catastrophic, senseless, and avoidable, but unstoppable due to systemic roadblocks, and cultural derangement - then there's no way to spin it - it does not reflect well on capitalism.
No way it could have been 50 years of idiotic policy. Yeah it was the free exchange of good and services for money.
You realize it all comes back to capitalism right, whether it's a communist dictatorship giving your company permission to pump shit into the atmosphere, or the bastian of democracy, the US, giving companies permission to sell bombs to dictators, and so on.
It still comes back to the companies themselves. And if the communist state(aka state-capitalism), or the representative democracy refuses to give them permission they will move to another place and try again, or turn to aggressive lobbying, because capitalism.
In case you've forgotten, capitalism is when you reward the investors over the workers with the surplus value the workers created, moreover, the investors control the company. The capitalist gets their investment back, and then they continue to get a chunk of the surplus created at the expense of the people who actually created said surplus, who instead get a wage. Oh yeah, and they control how the surplus is spent. What is the alternative? A co-op. In a co-op the workers do not get a wage, they get profits from the value they were responsible for, minus funding needed to purchase the next round of raw materials. In a co-op the company functions as a direct-democracy. The workers literally control the surplus and the way it is re-invested into the company.
In case you weren't aware, the majority of companies responsible for large chunks of the climate change pie, are/were driven by investors (and/or states) looking for profits without regards to the health and future of the people who produce said profits, the health of the locales in which they operate, or the health of the planet. The worker/citizen does not get a say, because they are kept on a wage, and because they literally have no say. This is why state-owned collectives are also the worst kind of capitalism. It's as if there is one company who holds the monopoly (the state) and the state is not 'the people' but a small number of, again, psychopaths who have nothing but quotas and profits to fulfill and positions to maintain.
A large portion of climate change is driven by a psychopathic disregard for both the worker and their environment.
Well at least you show your hand here. "Communism is capitalism when something bad is happening." I would love to hear you layout your definitions of capitalism and communism in a rigorous way.
You've replaced "person doing something I don't like" with "capitalist". Well in that case yeah, not hard to understand how you see capitalism as causing the world's problems.
Well, not the OP, but even the USSR did not call itself "communist" (it was a "socialist state on its way to communism" or something like that). I don't think it's unfair to make a distinction between "communism" as described by Marx and the "communist countries" which were/are at best socialist (at worst plain capitalist with a veneer of state participation) and ruled by a "communist party".
And I also think you can say that without attaching any value judgment to either cases: I'm not defending Marx's communism, it's an unreachable utopia and trying to implement it can only degenerate into the horrible examples we have seen.
At that point I'd argue, whatever it is that this person dislikes, capitalism is just an empty word to represent it. "Reality", or "the world" would appear more accurate to me.
Capitalism is a pretty clear idea - it's a society characterized by wage labour. Non-capitalist societies don't have the concept of selling your labour-time for a wage. That's why feudal societies aren't capitalist (they didn't have clocks, for one thing). That's why the soviet block was capitalist.
"You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means."
And on the other side of the coin there are endless historical and current examples of self-proclaimed communist states that are just the worst kind of capitalist monopolies, which is the concept you seem to have stuck in your craw. This is not historical revisionism. This was being pointed out from the beginning of Bolshevism (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jan_Wac%C5%82aw_Machajski)
Are you arguing that the fossil fuel industry was resisting those subsidies, incentives, privileges, free money, and tax incentives with every fibre of their being?
Do you think that producers in Soviet Russia weren't or in modern day Norway arent forcefully influencing policy like this and this some unique problem of capitalism or the US?
Exchanging money for goods and services is the most essential feature of capitalism. If you wish to prevent such exchanges, you need some strong socialist regulation or norm, like "politicians exist to serve the will of the people". Without it, what you call "bribery" and "corruption" isn't even considered wrong - it's just how the world works. Why shouldn't rich people be able to buy policy? They can buy everything else.
Trying to pass off corruption as a "most essential feature of capitalism" is disingenuous and simply wrong on many levels. There's no need for petty ideological jabs. If you have nothing to add to the discussion then refrain from adding noise to an otherwise interesting discussion.
Somehow, when George Stigler coined "regulatory capture" the world thought he was being novel. He wasn't.
I also don't really understand what a market is without a state, either theoretically, or practically. You need some independent guarantor of property rights to have property - since property itself is not a fact of nature, but rather a result of laws and rights. Practically, all states are by necessity involved in every legal transaction, either as a neutral arbiter in disputes, or as an active participant.
Property is based on potential violence. States are just organisations dispensing it on a controlled basis.
Using your argument, you could say that 'not looking at people funny' is a natural law, because I once got beaten up in a bus station in the midlands for it.
Also, paywall.
Where do you see any difference or contradiction? Subsidies were used to jump-start and increase demand and thus supply was created and adapted. That's textbook supply & demand, a hallmark of capitalism.
https://www.wsj.com/articles/a-reality-check-for-solar-and-w...
The successes are capitalism by definition; the costs are socialism by definition.
It's a Bloomberg article. There is no need to throw petty ideological jabs.