Time for someone who is a bit more accessible and savvy to take the FSF cause onwards.
The question though would be, will the FSF mission change or it's cause be diluted without RMS at the helm?
Time for someone who is a bit more accessible and savvy to take the FSF cause onwards.
The question though would be, will the FSF mission change or it's cause be diluted without RMS at the helm?
He just sacrificed his job and legacy to defend the honor of a friend.
What kind of person do you want leading the FSF, a mealy-mouthed politician?
He resigned after claiming that a victim of child sex trafficking, was "a member of (the trafficker's) Harem" and "entirely willing".
Defending his dead friends honour might be to raise the question of whether it was in fact his friend who was involved. He essentially gave the "but she wanted it" defence, for a dead man, who is accused of raping a child whom he had "borrowed" from another dead man, who is also accused of raping children.
> What kind of person do you want leading the FSF, a mealy-mouthed politician?
Most people would probably just be happy with someone who doesn't say the following about prostitution, adultery, necrophilia, bestiality, possession of child pornography, and even incest and pedophilia (and I quote):
> All of these acts should be legal as long as no one is coerced. They are illegal only because of prejudice and narrowmindedness.
(Meaning not willing, emphasis on presented .. as) How do you sleep at night knowing you are smearing other people with obvious falsehoods?
As I understand it, he opined that she may have been coerced into acting as though she were willing. Which is substantially different from your version of it.
And regarding sex trafficking/rape - sex with a 17 year old is almost never seen as rape legally. That's a mostly US thing. The age of consent is 16 generally; lower than 16 in parts of Europe. Everyone's entitled to an opinion but criticising someone for defending actions which are legal and - subject to opinion - moral seems like a bit of a boring waste of time.
But sure, carry on as usual because there’s always someone to defend RMS no matter how fucked his statements are.
Another poster asked why "adultery" was in the list of things in the quote, and I explained that I quoted the entire thing he said.
So fuck you, read something before you want to claim people are lying.
...and you just straight out lied there:
> He resigned after claiming that a victim of child sex trafficking, was "a member of (the trafficker's) Harem" and "entirely willing".
So, he says something a decade and a half ago, and then coincidentally 3 days after an email discussion where he defends a man alleged to have had sex with a victim of child sex trafficking, he suddenly "thinks adults should not do that".
WELL WHAT A REVELATION.
He called her a member of Epstein's Harem and said the "most likely" explanation is "she presented herself as entirely wiltingly"(sic)
A harem is a collection of wives or concubines. How exactly is a child sex slave either of those things?
RMS' theory is that a 70 year old man goes to a billionaire's private island and a 17 year old girl just happens to "present as willing" for sex and the guy asks no questions?
As other's have said, even if he didn't know she's 17, and somehow it never occurred to him to ask, it's the plot for a bad porno, it's not a plausible chain of events in reality, and it's definitely not the most likely scenario.
> "She was asking for it"
is very different from
> "I don't think my friend - who I knew well - was aware that she was coerced"
You, at least initially, argued that the former was the correct interpretation of his words, but to do so you did misquote him in a way that obviously altered the meaning of his words. Was that intentional or a mistake?
I don't have the context for the "harem" quote, but given how you presented the quote with regard to the victim's willingness, I think it's reasonable to conclude that RMS meant something other than what you insinuate.
In any case, it seems now that you recognize that the latter interpretation is correct, and you question whether RMS' position was reasonable. Fair enough. But tell me, would you know the difference between an 18yo prostitute (who is otherwise free to leave) and a 17yo slave?
Look, I think what Minsky did was wrong regardless, that he was foolish to let himself become entangled with a man like Epstein, and I think it's atrocious what happened to the young woman, but these two scenarios have vastly different legal consequences. Do you not think it is plausible that Minsky thought it was the first scenario?
For what it's worth, my initial thought when I heard that Minksy had been implicated in Epstein's ring, was that he was fully aware and complicit in the abuse. And Minksy may have in fact been fully aware, but RMS' words lead me to question that assumption because RMS actually knew the guy.
EDIT: hold the phone. Looking at some other sources suggests that Minksy may not have even had sex with the young woman. It sounds like she was coerced by Epstein to proposition Minsky, and that according to another witness Minsky turned her down [1]. It does not appear that the victim is actually accusing Minksy of assaulting her (though I could be missing evidence. If this is the case, then why is this argument even happening?
[1]https://old.reddit.com/r/linux/comments/d5a4dz/richard_stall...
This is untrue.
Sex with a coerced child is rape in everyday English(although it may have a different more specific legal term), and sex with a 17 year old prostitute is also rape (again, it may have a more specific legal term).
For all those places that have legal prostitution can you show me one that allows prostitution in under 18s?
It's concerning to me that you don't think his defence of pedophilia (not even just theoretical now - an actual specific case with an actual victim) would make him unpalatable to any people outside the world of pedophiles.
If you ask the average punter on the street who RMS is, they would shrug.