Does this extend beyond hearsay and having a "Knight for Justice (also: hot ladies)" sign on his door?
Also, where do these "decades" suddenly come from? His most vociferous accusers on social media wouldn't have been alive, or at least far too young to have attended MIT.
> which are the real reason he should have been removed from power.
Power? Exactly what power can a "visiting scientist"--a made-up quirky title, wield?
Or do you mean his power to travel around the world and talk about Free Software?
Do you even know who he is?
A published book from 2002? https://www.oreilly.com/openbook/freedom/ch14.html (The interview at the bottom.)
His own website about an incident in 1988? https://web.archive.org/web/20020204031846/http://www.stallm... I'm assuming you've seen by now the door with the "hot ladies" sign, and the times he mentioned pedophilia and necrophilia on his website because those got mentioned a lot more.
Nobody believed he would succeed, it was a lost fight by a lunatic. But it was this weird obsession that kept him motivated over the years. The appearance of Linux was both a success (the world finally got a complete operating system) and a failure (it forgot about GNU and focused on Linux). Then it turned out that proprietary software is not the only danger coming from greedy corporations: DRM, vendor lock-in, etc. RMS predicted many of these and was actively fighting against them. Whereas on a personal level he was the same Don Quixote as in the after-Symbolics period. Many people hated him for all possible reasons, and are celebrating now. What a sad time.
So what is your next step with me? Are you going to try to dox me and try to get me fired from my employer?
I also point out he was a slaveowner who had forced sex with his slaves.
I'm not going to turn around and say we need an official US church because I'm against his slaving and raping. Nor am I going to ignore his actual history.
Okay, as you say, "he was a jerk".
We shouldn't have a jerk as the head of the FSF. Kick him out for being a jerk.
It's not like I haven't heard stories about his creepy behavior for decades.
How come Guido van Rossum (to pick one) doesn't avoid women at all costs, yet doesn't have same treatment? I propose it's because what you describe isn't actually the issue.
Words matter, even if you can't feel bothered to motivate them, which is the problem in a nutshell in the first place.
edit: what's up with the downvotes
Except we're not, are we?
We're talking about RMS's firmly held, often repeated, views on child sexual abuse. He keeps saying that it's not that harmful; that images are fine; that coercion isn't force.
This latest episode, where he interjects his "well actually" to say that assault is the wrong word (because he mistakenly thinks assault requires use of force) is yet another example where he could have said nothing, or he could have done a little bit of research before speaking. Instead chose to deliver his weird definition of assault in a thread to defend the actions of Minsky.
That's a lie on your part isn't it?
There are very grave points to make about rms's statements but you are doing no one any favors with these statements and merely muddying the waters.
It would probably be a good idea to knock it off.
>I am skeptical of the claim that voluntarily pedophilia harms children.
Then, later,
> “There is little evidence to justify the widespread assumption that willing participation in pedophilia hurts children. Granted, children may not dare say no to an older relative, or may not realise they could say no; in that case, even if they do not overtly object, the relationship may still feel imposed to them. That’s not willing participation, it’s imposed participation, a different issue.”
Look at what he says here. Words like "willing" and "voluntary". This is a normalisation of child sexual abuse.
About Minsky:
> The injustice is in the word “assaulting”. The term “sexual assault” is so vague and slippery that it facilitates accusation inflation: taking claims that someone did X and leading people to think of it as Y, which is much worse than X.
> The accusation quoted is a clear example of inflation. The reference reports the claim that Minsky had sex with one of Epstein’s harem. (See https://www.theverge.com/2019/8/9/20798900/marvin-minsky-jef...)
> Let’s presume that was true (I see no reason to disbelieve it). The word “assaulting” presumes that he applied force or violence, in some unspecified way, but the article itself says no such thing. Only that they had sex.
Here he is clearly saying that "assault" requires use of force, and using this misinterpretation of the word to defend Minsky's actions.
He's wrong about the word assault. It does not require force or violence.
You can find your own Stallman quotes about child sexual abuse and bestiality.
Care to provide example of "that images are fine"?
> Words like "willing" and "voluntary"
Maybe look at the other words around those words for context.
> This is a normalisation of...
This is the infantilisation of language. Certain word "normalize" something, therefore adults are no longer allowed to be subjected to them. Language policing at its finest.
> using this misinterpretation of the word
Says who? Many people would assume the same. Should that be ignored because the legal definition, only fully understood by lawyers, differs? In terms of Minsky's reputation, it matters more what regular people think it means, than what definitions exist in law.
The common misconception wrt what "sexual assault" implies is often utilised by malicious publications and prosecutions - maybe it's time to clean up the language.
Yep. this