Prion disease can spread through air
newscientist.com
newscientist.com
I mean, seriously. A prion is a protein. Say you have a prion disease and you sneeze: it's now in the air, where it won't die if it dries out or is exposed to UV radiation like lots of non-air-traversing diseases.
In the experiment: a mad-cow-disease-for-mice was aerosoled (sp?) at lab mice, and they're surprised it infected the mice through the nasal nerves, which are damn-near exposed directly to air.
>"We were amazed at how efficiently they spread"
The efficiency may be surprising. How can the spreading be?
>The prions didn't need processing by the immune system first, as some other research has suggested
Really? It's a protein! Sure, some could need processing by the immune system, or gastric acids, to change how they are shaped, but certainly not all.
This being science, yes, it does need an experiment to show that it is so. I'm by no means arguing this is a superfluous use of funds. I'm arguing that believing otherwise and acting on it when designing your safety protocols is borderline gross negligence, and I wouldn't be surprised if it has killed someone already.
It seemed rather obvious to me at the time.
On the other hand, what's obvious in retrospect is not always obvious beforehand.
But expecting proteins to somehow change when aerosoled? And this is well after when the resistances to radiation and chemicals of some of the nasty ones of these was known. Look at a steak. Smell the steak. You're sniffing entire steak proteins (not that that's the majority of the smell, of course). Why would prions be any different?
Prions are fundamentally different from other diseases in that they're very dumb. Both viruses and bacteria have enormously complicated systems for infection that are specifically tuned to human physiology. A virus is many orders of magnitude too large to diffuse into a cell, so it has surface proteins that attach to human cell surface proteins in order to gain entry.
A protein doesn't have this (one can easily assume), but it's also too large to diffuse into a cell. So, yeah...I wonder what the molecular mechanism of this is? I have no idea.
"the underlying mechanism of infection remains unresolved" http://www.plosbiology.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjo...
"the exact physiological function of PrPC and the mechanism of neurotoxicity are still unknown" http://www.ingentaconnect.com/content/ben/cp/2010/00000007/0...
...I did run across this interesting paper suggesting that prions could be a widely-used regulatory mechanism rather than an aberration, however:
Prions aren't terribly well understood, there aren't a lot of them. If I'm not mistaken there are doubters that don't believe the some of the diseases attributed to prions are actually caused by them. I know it's still just theory how it is that they work.
At Colorado State University there are stables where deer were stabled while chronic wasting diseases was being studied and they are off limits forever now.
On the upside, it seems like they tend to be slower acting diseases but it's still a bit scary to think they can aerosolize.
Since mad cow disease, the neural and consumable parts were, yes. The cause was not, hard evidence that prions were the cause took a while, and a lot of people didn't / still don't believe it. But a lot of people still think the sun goes around the earth, so that's not a very good measure of something's accuracy.
So lets take this from another stance:
You have a chronic, deadly, incurable, unknown-cause disease that turns brains to mush. Lets study it without respirators prior to animal testing of aerosoled forms! That's sure to end well!
edit: why do people go on down-vote sprees? This whole line, and a few bystanders, just got nailed within a minute of each other. Is it a mis-placed sense of justice? Do I have enemies? Do they honestly think it works?
Anthropomorphizing such things is a silly because it confuses people. There is no intelligence in one or another. It is hard to discuss which one is more "advanced "because it is a function of how you define what " advanced" is.
One can postulate that advanced means : "how well it can spread".
Clearly prions can spread well enough and are very hard to eradicate. Perhaps then are more advanced than a virus. A virus has a lot more machinery involved while prions are just information based.
Their folding state _is_ the infection mechanism. There is nothing else extra required to infect, just a different configuration of an existing protein. That is truly fascinating. Even more fascinating is that the configuration state can be spread to other proteins without the need of DNA or RNA mechanisms. This is as efficient as it gets, it beautiful, deadly, and terrifying, all at the same time.
The rest of my post gave a very high-level explanation of how a virus infects a human cell. To explain it in full would take many hours verbally (it took me months in my program to even get up to speed on molecular biology, having come from a CS background).
I'll give some more detail, though: when I say "specifically tuned to human physiology" I mean "tuned" to an extreme level. A human cell is a bag of water, protein, and nucleic acids enveloped by a lipid bilayer. This lipid bilayer physically prevents anything larger than...I think a subset of very small molecules from entering the cell? I am very weak in biochem, so I don't know the exact parameters around this, but I do know for certain that a virus is many orders of magnitude too large to just "get in" to a cell.
In order to gain entry to the cell, the virus has to have a protein that is extremely specifically targeted to a human protein that sits on the surface of a human cell. Like, antibody-to-antigen level specific - this is the product of many many generations of evolution. After attaching to that protein, the virus performs a very biochemically specific action to inject its payload into the cell.
> Their folding state _is_ the infection mechanism
Er, not really. It's the infection mechanism once the prion is in the cell (since the proteins to which the infection spreads are in a cell). How does the protein get in the cell in the first place?
...that's what nobody knows. It can't just float in, again because of the lipid bilayer. It needs to be actively pulled into the cell. Why would that happen?
So? If a simple misconfigured protein can enter the cell without the complicated and specifically tuned machinery and is able to proliferate that way, isn't it more advanced. I would say so
I presume you are an engineer, so I'll make the assumption that you are quite fond of "complciated" things and assume them to be supperior to simpler things. But if both accomplish the same thing, should you consider the simpler thing to be supperior? I do.
> Er, not really.
I think we can agree as to what prions are -- misconfigured proteins. If we can agree that there is nothing more besides that, how is the folding state _not_ the infection mechanism. I am not talking about what the cell does, just what what is considered the transmitted -- the prion itself.
> ...that's what nobody knows.
Er, not really. They have some pretty good guesses.
http://www.plosone.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjourna...
""" How, then, does prion protein enter cells? It turns out to be by a mechanism called macropinocytosis. This involves the invagination and pinching off of a segment of cell membrane, and is used by cells to take up small amounts of liquids (macropinocytosis means "big cell drinking"). """
Also:
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC165614/
""" While still on the cell surface, prion protein leaves lipid ‘raft’ domains to enter non-raft membrane, from which it enters coated pits. The N-terminal domain (residues 23–107) of prion protein is sufficient to direct internalization, an activity dependent upon its initial basic residues (NH2-KKRPKP). """
You should be afraid of cancer, car wrecks and heart disease, they kill more people in one week than CJD does in a decade.
That's a nice phrasing... especially accurate for people (like me) who live in / near deer'd areas and nowhere near shark-country. I'll have to remember it for later use :)
But it's unlikely. Better to concentrate on risks which are more relevant and more likely.
Do you find driving or riding in an automobile terrifying? Eating a cheese burger? You're far more likely to die of heart disease or an automotive accident than prions or neutrino radiation.
I doubt that is even physically possible. Neutrinos are nearly impossible to detect because they don't interact with normal matter. In fact, I'm not sure they interact with much of anything. Does anybody know if they do interact with any other elementary particles?
Your point about concentrating on more likely risks is a good one though.
Consider, supernova 1987A radiated so many neutrinos that it increased the neutrino flux at Earth by 10,000x compared to the Solar flux. That event happened in a neighboring galaxy 168,000 light-years away, an event a mere 20 light-years away would result in a neutrino flux 70 million times greater than that (700 billion times normal background levels). A hypernova would release over 100 times as much energy.
Indeed, some researchers believe that some mass extinctions in Earth's past might be due to such events: http://lanl.arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9505028
Fortunately for us stars that would be both large enough to go supernova and close enough to present such a threat should be quite bright and thus very unlikely to have escaped our notice (hypernovae candidates as well, if we're lucky).
And, to reply up a couple levels: some cheeseburgers, yes.
I find that very interesting. It is akin to an cell automata -- a glider perhaps.
2.5 percent? As in 1 part in 40 tissue? Is that not as ridiculous as it sounds?
Edit: Thinking on it, that probably means the suspension which was aerosolized rather than the aerosol itself, which explains the conclusion that 10% suspensions might be dangerous to handle. Is that normally how you measure aerosol concentration?