> As for the use of photos of me that are owned by other people, I'm pretty certain that neither CCPA nor GDPR cover those.
You're talking about specific laws, and I'm talking about general principles. The dichotomy I'm supposing is between complete anonymity and complete ownership over my own data. Owning data means being able to restrict how other people use it.
No expects to be unidentifiable in a photo where their face is visible. But if I own my face, I expect to be able to issue a takedown request to sites who post images of my face without my permission. If I genuinely own my address, or my contacts, and a third-party site makes them publicly available, I should be able to do something about that, the same way that I would be able to restrict them from distributing a piece of IP I owned.
CCPA and GDPR don't cover individuals, just companies. This is a compromise, because it's just not feasible right now to have a version of GDPR that covers what ordinary citizens share. But there's nothing special about companies. If I'm committed to a world where I own my data, I don't want my rights to vanish just because the information was posted on a blog instead of Facebook.
And that's where you start to see this conflict -- because in order to maintain control over data, you have to, well... maintain control over data. You have to know who's posting it and who it belongs to. People who advocate primarily for anonymity are opposed to that kind of world. Their extremes look different.
In the real world, most people will be somewhere in the middle. They'll lean towards data ownership on some things, and anonymity on others. For example, I doubt that many people on HN believe that companies should be able to operate anonymously. Even though anonymity/ownership is not a binary choice, different people are going to be lean towards different sides of the continuum, and that's where you see these conflicts.