Hacker News Reader

Comment by gapo | Hacker News Reader

Definition of dystopia

the body language is unnverving. the insincere tics in the faces of the young women, the stilted swinging of the shoulders, the weak fist-squeezing of the young men with the awkward eye-popping. The deer in headlights postures...

it all just reeks of coercion and young people trying to please but afraid and uncomfortable. Perhaps it's just a bad video director. Maybe the video director is trying to communicate their own discomfort. Maybe the producers see it all and delight in how much power they have... This video is evidence of their grip.

I think they are simply bad actors.

You have no idea how true this is, try watching the TV over there!

Exactly. You look at this, remember that it'll be making its way around the world (slowly at first, admittedly) and it's impossible to ignore the little internal voice where your conscience used to be whispering "kill yourself".

I really don’t think the Chinese are interested in exporting their governance system.

The USA and the Chinese governments are not so different. All that ideology bollocks is window dressing; the API. The back end is the same.

No, but all western countries are interested in getting some of that control for themselves...

If you consider what governments track today and what was considered "totalitarian surveillance" back in McCarthy era, it's clear where things are headed.

Or consider how many extra bureaucratic checks, controls, and laws exist now, compared to 1950 or 1920...

They used to though.

Years ago in communist Poland my father accidentally wound up in some kind of Chinese event where the organizers would give away Mao's Red Book.

At the exit there were two local secret service agents who in turn would politely, but firmly ask for the booklet to be surrendered to them, since this was a flavour of communism not enjoyed by the Big Brother, so illegal.

They used to when Mao was alive and the country was engulfed by misguided idealism. After Mao was gone they realized what a mistake that was, hence why China started reforming. The party’s official stance is that Mao was 70% right (pre-cultural revolution contributions to freeing the country from oppressors, giving common people power), 30% wrong (cultural revolution).

So whether they used to or not is not relevant.

An outsider could perhaps look at capitalism in the same way.

China is capitalist.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com