Talking Is Throwing Fictional Worlds at One Another
nautil.us
nautil.us
That's beginning to change[0][1].
[0] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5523951/#S24tit... [1] https://www.wired.com/2007/04/esp/
There are things I cannot see or hear even though my eyes and ears are good enough — the appeal of football, which key music is playing in, or (to the surprise of friends who like that sort of thing) if certain images are ”consensual BDSM” or ”assault”.
There are thoughts that I am incapable of thinking.
Given the problem of induction and its relation to the “no free lunch” theorem in AI, I believe that this is not merely an imperfection of my mind, but an inevitability.
I remember someone (philosopher perhaps, scandinavian I think) who had a paper / rant on the utter impossibility of understanding one another.
From memory it was in a form of a list, with one of the items being something like
"If something can be misunderstood, it will be"I think we ought to admit that true depth of thought is just about incompatible with the non-stop, clickbait oriented, demands of the internet.
The problem is that it is usually very well hidden right in front of us. It takes a lot of life experience and careful thought to get a sense of it (exposure to ideas of others certainly helps as well). It isn't easily communicated or understood. We have no rigorous tools for working with it. We are like the blind men and the elephant.
And then of course, doing something meaningful with it is another question entirely. It happens, certainly, but it is non-trivial. Art, in all its forms, is perhaps the easiest example (another is writing HN comments :p).
Some people take these difficulties as reasons to largely dismiss it or spend no time thinking about it. I think that is a mistake. The elephant still exists even if we can only perceive a piece of it.
However, it does seem that because of all this, much of the time there are better things to do (unless you are a philosopher or some other specialist!). Fortunately, we can slowly explore this profoundness as a background task, with the occasional punctuated intensive investigation as life demands, while going about our daily lives.
I agree with this, but I don't think Nautilus routinely hits the mark.
My comment wasn't only directed at you. I used the opportunity as an excuse to ramble a bit.