I think people either should try to maintain their own distro, be a maintainer for their distro of choice or stop complaining about the decisions maintainers from their distro take for them.
I mean, at least in Arch systemd seemed to be the obvious choice: it reduced the complexity for the maintainers. Arch used to be a combination of multiple shells scripts maintained by Arch package maintainers. Since systemd they can use the .service file that multiple programs already have upstream, or they can write themselves one that is much easier and less error prone than the shell script approach used before.
I am sure that the maintainers from Debian, Ubuntu, Fedora, OpenSUSE, Madriva, etc. all analyzed the advantages/disadvantages of migrating to systemd vs. maintaining their in-house solution (that they all had before, one way or another). If you still discord from them, why are you using one specific distro? You can pick any other one that is not using systemd, like Devuan, Void Linux, Alpine, etc.
Instead of saying it will be optional, just say it up front: this is what Red Hat wants, so it's coming to your distro soon too, whether you like it or not, because it will become a dependency of systemd, or vice versa.
It's the lying about it that I can't stand.
Avoiding systemd is not difficult, it is just that using systemd makes things easier. You have one codebase shared between multiple distros where most of your init logic is, instead of having to maintain your own init scripts somewhere by yourself.
> because it will become a dependency of systemd, or vice versa.
This is not true. I don't know many things that are dependend of systemd running as a init system.
Well, for sysadmins who are in charge of hundreds of systems in datacenters and are accustomed to upgrading regularly, it's really not that easy.
Basically at some point you had a choice: you either ship Systemd or can't ship Gnome because of GDM's dependency on Systemd. At this point we knew we're royally screwed up. It's almost funny that in Debian you can replace any element of the system, even the Linux kernel with a BSD one, but you can't replace the init system, even though several alternatives exist. Our problem with Systemd is the lack of choice.
Void Linux is using GDM with elogind and seems fine: https://github.com/void-linux/void-packages/blob/master/srcp...
> even the Linux kernel with a BSD one
You know, Debian GNU/kFreeBSD is as most a fork of Debian as Devuan. They share most of the packages definitions, however some core parts (like the init scripts) are _very_ different.
> but you can't replace the init system, even though several alternatives exist
Well, you can. It is just that Debian maintainers don't want to maintain this complexity in their own system. Supporting only one init system is already difficult, imagine supporting N init systems like you're suggesting (and this includes bug reports: do you really think that this is a good usage of the time from maintainers to support that niche init system with 3 users?).
However there is nothing impeding you to use your own Debian installation with any init system you want. Or even better: switch to Devuan.
Sigh... don't believe the FUD, there's a standing Debian Technical Committee decision [1] that multiple init systems must be supported, it's just that the Devuan people don't want to work on a distro that includes a systemd source package in its archive, so instead of maintaining the sysvinit scripts in the Debian archive they went off forking.
[1] https://lists.debian.org/debian-devel-announce/2014/08/msg00...
Huh what? The Debian discussion was completely in the open, and I recommend reading it, so you know why people choose systemd.
There was no Lennart’s influence, everyone was their own people. No one had red hat agenda. All they wanted a better init system, it ended up being a choice between systemd and upstart, and systemd won with a small margin. A later GR vote across thousands of debian debs confirmed the decision.
Really, why do those theories gets repeated? We are not talking about commercial companies and back room office politics, it is all in the open.
And BTW, if you don't like the way that Gnome is going you can fork it or use another desktop. There are multiple desktops for Linux that are very polished and doesn't depend on systemd.
Sounds like your beef is with a specific distro, not systemd in general.