Wikipedia Wales says Apple's App Store is a threat to openness online
thinq.co.uk
thinq.co.uk
o Apple does not have a monopoly on the Mobile Internet.
o Apple's support for open HTML 5 protocols is stronger
than any previous generation of Mobile Platforms that
connected to the internet.
We can critique Apple in a lot of places with regards to their AppStore (though, it's gotten much better lately) - but, ruining the Mobile Internet is not one of them.I seem to recall that the iPhone was actually the _first_ really decent phone browser that you could use to connect to the internet - if anything, Apple spawned the "Open" Mobile Internet.
(Which is not to say they're doomed. They'll probably keep a healthy marketshare, just not the dominant position they used to have.)
- Mobile providers throttling particular apps
- Mobile providers and bandwidth caps
- The balkanization of networking (Facebook)
- Pushing a patent-encumbered standard for video
(Apple is involved here, but is only one player of several.)
EDIT: Technically h.264 is "open"Open is a horribly diluted word and there's no way imaginable you can say anything is "technically" or "not technically" open.
Now - how much of the Mobile Internet requires that you use an Apple product? Apple just doesn't have enough market dominance to result in more than a trivial portion of the Mobile Internet to be written _specifically_ for Safari/IOS Browers.
Wales is completely off his rocker here. As long as Firefox, Opera, Chrome, and yes, IE, continue to have a strong presence as browsers (and I don't see that changing anytime soon), and as long as Anddroid, WP7, and others start rolling out first class smart phones, Apple will not be a threat to the Mobile Internet.
This is one of those cases where lack of a market leader actually results in a better adherence to standards. As long as the focus is "Build an ACID3 Compliance Browser" for the vendors, and developers write "ACID3 Compliant Websites" - we'll be in fine shape (modulo the recent Video controversy)
He doesn't like that Apple is the gatekeeper on their App Stores, as if the consumer doesn't have any other hardware options out there...
> Founders: Steve Wozniak, Ronald Wayne and DEFINITELY NOT Larry Sanger