It seems like a pretty big loss if these types of cases cannot be solved in the future.
It seems like a pretty big loss if these types of cases cannot be solved in the future.
GEDMatch doesn't even do the DNA testing themselves.
https://www.gedmatch.com/tos.htm
>You understand that future genealogical and non-genealogical uses may be developed, including uses that GEDmatch cannot predict or foresee. If you find any of these current or future uses unacceptable, do not provide Raw Data to GEDmatch, and remove any of your Raw Data already provided to this Site.
I fail to see what this has to do with suspending the US Constitution.
Hah, this reminds me of those drug commercials with disclaimers not to take the drug being advertised if you're allergic to the drug being advertised.
Most of our rules about what police can do to gather evidence is based on 19th century America.
So we came up with compromises like...
If a suspect is holding a piece of documentation personally, a search warrant is required; but if a business holds the records, a subpoena is enough. But suddenly almost all of our correspondence, personal photos, etc, is in cloud providers' hands, and ditto for basically all of our financial transactions. The rules stayed the same, but as the world changed privacy evaporated.
Or, the police can record where anyone out in public is going. Because they can hardly follow everyone, right? There's an inherent bound on that power. But then you get things like license plate cameras and facial recognition recording the movement of nearly all humans.
Effectively, the police became much more powerful compared to the past with no changes in laws to do it.
They are not making just themselves findable by DNA. They are making their extended family findable by DNA, and I don't imagine they have gotten the whole family's consent before doing so.
I can post on Facebook that I was with you at a certain time and a certain place; I don't need your permission even though law enforcement might use that to find you. Or if I post a picture of us at a baseball game, I don't need your permission just because it could be used to find out you were somewhere.
If I thought a relative of mine was a criminal, and went to the police, and said "I think my cousin committed a crime, check my blood"
Would that be ok?
Some suffer from strong taboos against snitching on family members.
Some suffer from an overabundance of civic duty.
Anything you (or your relatives) submit to, let's say, 23andme, is fair game and you should assume the feds have it and can search it.
It's for the sole purpose of being findable by people with similar DNA to you. Its purpose is not to allow anyone to look you up by your DNA like you are implying here.
https://www.sciencenews.org/article/family-tree-dna-sharing-...
Law enforcement also uses CODIS and your profile is not deletable there (unless your comment was narrowly tailored to the specifics of this article, in which case my comment is a non sequitur).
It's a fine line and from personal experience - can be more devastating when criminals can abuse and game the system to use such liberties to evade capture and punishment. Alas I can not elaborate as ongoing, but dam. Criminals sure know how to play the system better than the system I have found out the hard way.
Commercial DNA databanks are a problem for a lot of reason. You shed small amounts of DNA absolutely everywhere, and it can absolutely be transported on shoes, coats, and the like. Modern testing can pick up these trace amounts in place where you haven't been. The Innocence Project has already overturned a few convictions based on tiny DNA traces of this variety. The commercial databases just give cops the opportunity to perform dragnet searches for any and everyone whose DNA shows up in an area of interest, it's scary and sloppy.
I'll also point out that at least i the US, the constitution is the backstop for EVERYONE's civil rights. If cops are allowed to trample on the rights of the accused in the name of "safety" then there will be no protection for anyone.
But shall leave it at that. Just please don't blindly dismiss a person's experience as FUD.
You're just scaremongering. You have a policing problem for sure, but simple video or eyewitness reports would solve your problem. There's no additional need for the power to perform dragnet searches that can and do drag innocent people into the justice system.
Authoritarianism isn't the answer to petty crime.
Oh yes, more so when 37% of the police in my area haven't been veteted and leak information to criminals more than we have rain. But this is London.
Sorry, i'm running on a tangent and slightly off-topic and respect and acknowledge what your saying. I'm just more aware of the aspect that those 10 people that get away with crime can impact more than one innocent found guilty. What with all the privacy and civil protection laws, criminals do know how to game and play the system better than those who control and run the systems.
As for DNA - it should be default no, but equally allow those who want to opt-in and allow their DNA to be used to help maybe identify some genetic relative of a crime. But like most things - no clear cut solution and when it swings so far one direction, you end up with a powerless system that struggles to fulfill it's remit due to being buried in red-tape.
Your DNA and mine are basically everywhere we go, and many places we've never been due to transfer. Forensic DNA tests can now easily identify these traces of you from places you have never been. Commercial DNA databases now allow police to target people who weren't previously identified as suspects by conventional means. The combination of the two can and has led to innocent people being swept up in the grinding gears of the justice system.
There is little to no oversight, and courts/juries aren't aware of this problem. This issue also creates perverse incentives within the system that will allow bad cops and prosecutors to pin crimes on people they don't like, and use DNA databases to back into the appearance of scientific evidence. There is immense moral hazard here.
That kinda thing?
Let's assume the other two have solid allabies with recites and witnesses. You were at home alone during the crime and have no solid alibi. What do you as an innocent person do in that situation? You have to hire a lawyer, and possibly face a trial where you could serve time in prison for a crime you did not commit. If you are convicted, you go to jail, the case is closed, and the real criminal goes free to perhaps continue committing crimes. Your life is ruined, and anyone who knows and believes you will lose all faith in the system. The tax payers money is wasted jailing you, the victim receives no real justice, and all of society loses.
Courts just aren't prepared for this. Judges and the general public all believe that DNA evidence is basically magic. This is a real problem.
So imagine in your fine example that you later in life end up with the police taking your DNA for something else, even if to eliminate your DNA from forensics upon an aggravated burglary at your partners flat as an example. The police computer then pings about the previous alleyway crime and this is years later. You now find that proving were you actually was back then, harder than more recently. CCTV from a bar you was at - all gone due to data protection retention laws that curtail how long it can be held. Google - nope as some law came in that stops them keeping that info.
You kinda get down to the situation that your only assured safety from past and future crimes is to self monitor and track. Heck - I literally bug my own house and carry a tracking monitor due to tangent issues, to protect me from such mistakes/abuse etc.
ALso having done Jury duty, it's not just the evidence and opinion of guilty or not, but how that evidence is presented and the impact of the dominant alpha's in that jury. Whilst that should not be a factor for the most enlightened (general makeup of posters upon these forums), the population has few discriminators upon the makeup of juries - age, not below average IQ and criminal record or mostly - lack of.
So privacy laws are great and have many upshots, they can equally have some downsides. Why I feel that choice should be down to individuals and sure, opt-out by default. But you can start to see why opt-in also helps, so you can clear things up in a timely manner and not suddenly 15 odd years later get arrested for a crime you did not commit and the quick simple proof has long gone, making innocence much harder to play out.
Yes, I suppose from what I'm saying, I'd be effectively violating the choice of relative. A fair and valid point and does raise many avenues of individuals opting in exposing others thru their choices. I guess shopping loyalty cards - the person who does the family shopping is revealing what the entire household likes in many ways.
But equally a tough choice, with many aspects - pro and con to weigh in. With that, I'll concede as without all the options fully outlines, the forced opt-out approach as this is the case, does make much more sense.
Thank you for a wonderful debate and I certainly learned something from it.
And again, rampant heroin isn't an inevitable consequence of freedom. We don't have to destroy civil rights to get rid of heroin, it's just that the actual root cause social solutions are a lot more nuanced than sending men with guns to use force. But more force is an easy story to sell to the public, and it happens to be convenient to the people at the top.
But the real issue as you touch upon is the underlying issues, the drivers for going into addiction and such drugs, that's where support is needed and more so, cheaper for prevention than support later on. Yet both area's are seriously lacking and the whole mentality of fighting the fires instead of fighting the sources keeps playout out.
For instance, 25% of death row prisoners in Florida were found innocent.
Criminals know how to play the game but so do prosecutors who withhold evidence, corrupt policemen, judges who give harsher sentences to poor and minorities, the state governments who underfund the public defenders office but give the prosecution unlimited funds for experts, etc.
I would much rather the guilty go free than innocent people be wrongfully convicted.
https://www.floridaphoenix.com/2019/06/04/more-prisoners-are...
I agree with what you're saying but the US usually has more than 15,000 murders per year not several hundred.
Doesn't that still mean that more people are dying in car accidents than in homicides? It looks like a minimum of twice as many. (Might be a little fuzzy though because if someone is killed by someone who used a car as the murder weapon, does that get categorized as only a homicide? Only a motor vehicle fatality? Or both? I don't really know.)
Many others die from opioid overdose and medical issues. Indeed, 2.8m people die yearly in USA.
Perspective.
How many people do you know. How many people do you know who died in car accidents. For most people that number is zero or one, maybe two. The average person gets in a car accident like once every 17yr (forget where I heard that) and fatal accidents are a tiny, tiny subset of that. They really are rare compared to how many people are in the US and how much driving those people do.
Murders are far, far more rare than car accidents, practically nonexistent for people who don't make their living in the drug trade.
The point is that they are statistically very rare events overall so increasing the risk of a big problem in the long term (by throwing away our restrictions on what government can and can't do to "find criminals") in order so solve a really tiny one doesn't seem wise.
And it's worth thinking about what causes loss of life expectancy in our culture, to consider what problems deserve the most attention. Both homicide and car accidents are rather significant.
So far I haven't heard any remotely convincing argument.
When it moves down the ladder to omniscience about citizen activities in general, it gets scarier.
No one doubts that license plate camera databases of citizen movements, Stringray devices, etc, can help solve a whole bunch of crimes. But they can also be used to crush civil liberties in the hands of an authoritarian state. They can also be used for petty abuses of power. So it is with this, of being able to attribute any genetic information left behind to the particular person it's from.
We have a whole lot of laws, and almost everyone breaks some every day. Very efficient law enforcement able to "solve these crimes" easily can be wielded against anyone.
Let's look at Trump. Like or loathe him, reasonable people will agree if there was a skeleton or three in his past it would be used to attempt to unseat him. He, however, lived most his life before tech existed. So what will happen to a President 50 years from now? I'm not knocking Monks here--but who among us has emulated their legendary behavior throughout their entire lives?
So I for one do believe those nightmare scenarios will come true.
It's part of our past, and part of our present to some degree. Not to mention what we see happening in some other places in the world. Why would we not believe abuses would be part of our future, especially if they become easier?
The tech is so simple and cheap that this surveillance will be part of life whether the state participates or not.
Unfortunately the Germans found those same records very useful a couple of years later, and they tracked down the families that had filled in "jewish" as religion.
In France such a central register did not exist, for cultural and political reasons. Even today the French state state has explicitly chosen not to keep per-race statistics on crime etc.
WW II stats:
------------
Jews dead in France: 25%Jews dead in the Netherlands : 95%
Just because you trust your current government, and because you are currently not a minority, does not mean that you run the what-ifs.
Really gets down to DNA being useful and abusable in many ways. The real onus should as always with such personal data - be in the hands of the individual and with that, the ability to opt-in/out choice needs to be there. I'd have no problem of my DNA to be used to help identify a crime perpetrated by some genetic relative, some on the other hand would not. But the choice should be with the individual and a complete ban, removes that right from those who would want to aid justice.
When things can be used for good and bad, blanket bans do not work out as well and it should be down to a default position of no, but the ability for individuals to opt-in.
Something wildly unlikely can always happen that turns your good intentioned idea into a genocidal nightmare or other disaster.
So an honest application of this principle would result in never doing anything. That would of course be impossible.
But usually proponents only apply this "you never know what might go wrong!" kind of thinking for things they already dislike.
So in practice it boils down to "we shouldn't do things I have a bad feeling about, because you never know etc". And that is possible to argue for!
In reality, there are always risks, and you have to weigh them realistically against the reward, and accept that occasionally things go bad.
Canada has several hundred murders per year. Baltimore alone has several hundreds.
Privacy is a human right, just as important as freedom. You cannot just take that away from everybody. This is putting the whole populace under general suspicion in each case.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Statute_of_limitations#Heinous...
I'm not surprised that a murderer wouldn't want that "crap dredged up", but maybe the family might feel differently?
I still don't think they should be dragnetting DNA databases for relatives, however.