Many of my students came from schools where they learned a method called "guess and try," where you plug answers into the problem and see if one works. This is a speedy way to dispatch multiple choice tests.
To my students, "show your work" meant showing some evidence that they had solved the problem themselves. They thought I was policing them, when I really would have liked to engage them at a bit higher level.
In my view, "show your work" means, loosely speaking, to create a fictitious chain of reasoning and present it in a style learned from the textbook and classroom presentations. I call it fictitious because they might have guessed the answer and then worked backwards from it to obtain the steps. I could handle saying that a bright student should be able to do this, but that it should be taught.