It's true that lots of AIR apps are nasty, and that's why it gets a bad name. We agreed that we'd only use AIR if we could make the app beautiful and fast through our hard work, and we were able to do that (go try it and see). As a result we've saved a lot of time, only have to write features once, and have a consistent user experience between all users. Even Alex himself enjoyed it and provided some feedback: http://twitter.com/#!/al3x/status/25370589657042945. Note that the feedback is mostly minor improvements, not "wow this app is gross". Of course, if you want to hate something you'll find a way - http://bit.ly/eCRyMc.
"Settling for mediocrity" is not a great way to describe us, however. Mediocre is defined as "not very good" which is how we view the current state of group chat services. Deciding to use a self-hosted IRC or Jabber server is settling for mediocrity (feature comparison: http://www.hipchat.com/compare).
Bottom line: we're building a tool that is a joy to use and allows teams to get more work done.
And don't settle for mediocrity, just work smart.