What is needed to really reduce costs is a payment system that eliminates error and irregularities, or which uses AI to handle them.
What is needed to really reduce costs is a payment system that eliminates error and irregularities, or which uses AI to handle them.
Perhaps some kind of... clearing house, which could be automated?
In the US we have a dozen startups for you to send money to your friends. In most of the world you just do a bank transfer.
I pay my rent and utilities with ACH, but I know people who still don't have that option and are stuck in the dark ages of checks or credit cards with processing fees.
I have accounts with multiple credit unions, and one doesn't permit online ACH transfers and another takes 3+ days to do it. I'm currently trying to consolidate those accounts but even that's a huge hassle. It's nearly 2020 and the form the payroll company my employer uses wants a voided check from me to change where my direct deposits go! I don't have checks and haven't written a personal check in probably 15 years.
We keep scratching our heads looking for that magic future tech solution to our problems (AI! AI for everything!) when we actually just need to fix adoption of the freaking 45 year old standardized solutions right in front of us.
Checks have always been an almost entirely American aberration and a bad solution on all sides. It took us almost 15 years after Europe to adopt chip cards, and we're still swiping in places and almost nobody requires a pin for security. NFC adoption isn't great either outside affluent areas. We're not lacking new financial solutions, we're lacking proper adoption of the solutions we already have and the rest of the world is happy to use.
Not everyone wants a change. One person's costs are another person's revenues. There are also a lot of managers managing organizations that process fraud, errors, and other irregularities. Costs don't matter if you can charge enough in fees and interest.
In the case of chip cards, the US wasn't about to pay for the French smartcard patents. In general, financial technology is a patent thicket and its best to wait 20 years before implementing new ideas unless you have really positive financial case and can be sure you have the IP locked down.
I suspect there's also the old argument that standardisation takes regulation, and regulation is evil. Government should stay out of this (oh, btw, Government - can you just pay the next tranche of subsidies directly into the executive bonus account. Thanks!).
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interac_e-Transfer
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interac
It works quite well.
Other times, I've had e-transfers delayed by a few hours. This is fine if I'm sending off rent, but what if I'm trying to buy something off craigslist? I can't exactly hang out with the seller for a few hours waiting for Interac to get their shit together. This isn't an email issue: Interac acknowledges that transfers may take "up to a day" on their site.
Further, e-transfers cost money to both send and receive at most/some institutions, while cheques are free. E-transfers also can't be scheduled in advance like post-dated cheques can.
Cheques may be antiquated tech but they're still very much useful for certain applications.
I do use them to make transfers between banks because they’re virtually immediate rather than several days long pretty regularly these days without fault.
Checks are down to a third of what they were in 2000. The fastest growing type of non-cash payment is debit card, and a lot of these are chip and PIN.