> “AlphaGo uses more electricity than any human; does it not win at Go?”
I know you have a prolific reputation, and I mean this sincerely, but did you actually read the link?
The point was that with power constraints, the class of possible algorithms is restricted heavily, requiring development of an understanding closer to what algorithms a person must use in their mind.
If you present me a Go-based Turing test, and I’m pretty fooled by AlphaGo, except I get blasted by the hot air venting out from a big cooling system, then it probably reveals to me that it’s failed the test (at least until some far future where there are life forms that regularly vent computer-levels of hot air from cooling systems).
This effect is much more pronounced with a larger system like Watson, hence the article.
> “If a NN uses more electricity than 150 watts to classify images at superhuman rates, why does this matter?”
It matters because pure computing achievements are not isolated from their resource constraints. If a NN can generate flawless natural language responses, but it takes 1000 years per word, we would not be interested and certainly would not see it as valuable progress towards artificial intelligence (likely not even strong AI, but surely not tool AI, there just aren’t a lot of ways to demonstrate a conceptual breakthrough so wasteful of resources). Intelligence is (partly) generating language within human-level time constraints. Why not also human level RAM, physical volume, material density, etc. Solving it within these constraints is much more valuable than solving it without them.
Likewise with power. Maybe using 100x power is an OK tradeoff for pure tool
usage (heck, I work professionally in computer vision and NLP and I make this concession to use machine learning models running on computers to solve my work daily).
But that doesn’t mean it’s an ok trade-off for the philosophical side of the questions, like approximating a Turing test or understanding how far we must go from modern deep neural networks to the algorithms an actual brain is using. And, ultimately, these will move from being philosophical issues to being practical ones.
> “Is there some reason to think that AI can never be misused or cause problems if it happens to use somewhat more electricity?”
Huh? Where did I ever say anything like this? I mean, humans misuse intelligence and cause problems on less power.
It sounds like you’re trying to propagate your feelings about the “green” aspect of the post into what I’ve said, but if you’ll notice, I did not say anything about that, and don’t particularly care about this OP article’s take on “green” AI power consumption, it’s not related at all to what I’m talking about. (Plus they are more focused on power demands at training time, while I’m interested in power constraints, like runtime or space constraints, at inference time).