Hundreds of Propaganda Accounts Targeting Iran and Qatar Removed from Facebook
buzzfeednews.com
buzzfeednews.com
> Increasingly, we're seeing more PR firms or strategic communication firms offer computational propaganda as a service for all sorts of clients, including governments.
Now consider this, if this happens at this scale for the small cost of $150.000 how many pr-firms are engaging in propaganda against some commercial target right now without your ever noticing?
Even on HN the past few years the number of propaganda posts and comments has gone up and up and up. Continues to increase right now.
What can people do though? Other people have the right to free speech. You just have to try to tune out all of the Anti-Tech, Anti-China, Anti-US, Anti-Amazon, Anti-Iran, Anti-Trump, Anti-Immigrant, Anti-Obama, Anti-minority, Anti-etc etc etc blather.
I definitely agree that a lot of previously unaware people took notice.
Then at least something in a displayed political ad would be true.
They're ok with lies that are paid advertisements.
Just to add on a bit to other replies, banning people from a private service, socially ostracizing them, vigorously criticizing them, attempting legal forms of economic retaliation (like boycotts), etc are all part of Free Speech too. Free Speech is about not having physical force used to shutdown the market of ideas, because of the millennia of proven destructive effects that has. That doesn't mean all speech and ideas are of equal value though, far from it. The point is to push judging of that into softer spheres, where minds can potentially change (sometimes over generations) and room can remain on the margins for new things to put down roots, and where hopefully eventually higher value ideas can grow. But constant judging is still there.
Constant non-violent but vigorous efforts to resist propaganda and the like through revealing it and acting to counter and restrain it are real actions, and completely within the bounds of Free Speech.
How do you know this? What do you use to decide? As far as I can tell, the way most people decide this is: if I don't like it, it's propaganda. Nobody thinks that consciously, of course, but it matches what people say surprisingly closely. That has no evidentiary value, except as an indication of what someone dislikes. You learn this very quickly if you're responsible for the community as a whole, because people have such different likes and dislikes that basically everything contentious gets dismissed as 'propaganda' or some such abuse.
Two things seem clear: (1) propaganda exists; (2) "I don't like it" is no way to identify it. There needs to be something more objective. When people are worried about abuse on HN and we look into it, our bar is that we have to see at least some evidence, somewhere, of something amiss. That's as low as the bar can get, yet even that is enough to reveal that way over 90%, probably over 99%, of perceptions of propaganda have no basis beyond the feelings of the perceiver.
\end{jest}
More seriously...
The thing about propaganda is that once someone starts believing it, that someone can potentially (and often does) spread it organically. Hacker News can inadvertently be a hotbed for propaganda spreading of all sorts without even a single bot or paid poster/commenter. I know I've fallen victim to that before, parroting something that ended up being misleading at best because I had been convinced through disinformation that it was the truth and therefore needed spread. I therefore tend to be cognizant of when others appear to be doing the same, seeing in them the same patterns I expressed.
In other words: just because it ain't violating the HN community guidelines doesn't mean it ain't propaganda.
That's certainly true. But what objective criteria are there for doing something about it?
I think the best bet is to call out (or at least note) the common patterns as they pop up. For example, I know you happen to hold a dim view of accusing others of "whataboutism", but that does happen to be a very common form of modern-day organically-spreading propaganda ("Who are you to say my country does evil things when your country does evil things, too?", says the accidental propagandist, forgetting that two wrongs don't make a right and that one country doing evil things does not excuse another country from doing evil things), and it's important to be able to identify that for what it is. Granted, sometimes that line of thinking is often valuable in the reverse (i.e. "I don't think it's right that your country is doing this evil thing, so I shouldn't be okay with my country doing a similar evil thing."), but it doesn't seem like those sorts of comparisons are typically done with that sort of self-awareness or good-faith desire to understand the other side of the debate.
The problem is that there are two different phenomena surrounding those words. The first is real abuse; the second is people labeling comments they dislike as abuse because they can't imagine anyone could hold them in good faith. As far as we can tell, the second problem is much more widespread than the first.
I don't think that "most" is accurate.
It is not hard to recognize propaganda, even when it coincides with one's established views.
In elementary school we had many quizzes and drills on this sort of stuff as part of our civics courses. The problem is, I doubt schools teach this stuff anymore, even though this kind of very basic critical thinking is very important for a functioning society.
Elementary school is a pretty different context. Schoolchildren may be more reliable on this, actually. Although they tend to imbibe the views of their parents, they haven't yet had time to build up the same fixed emotional habits around them.
I don't think so. Propaganda works by convincing you without making you suspicious. If you can recognize it, it has already failed. Of course, not all propaganda is actually concerned with convincing you. Most of it is probably only concerned with convincing a majority, your minority opinion might not be worth the effort.
Throwing some ideas here since it's a bit of a meta-discussion but on topic.
I think other social media sites have realized that there's more than "legitimate users" as well. Identifying propaganda is tricky and it certainly can't be just "because I don't like it" but there are some factors that can be checked:
- Accounts focused on one or few (thorny) themes (they might talk about other things for some "reputation laundering" but they're mostly focused on some specific subjects)
- Activity times not corresponding to the purported user location (and centered around "working hours").
- Linguistic patterns also not corresponding to the purported user location (or suggesting usage of automated translation).
- Pushing biased or misleading information.
An example of this problem https://news.vice.com/en_us/article/kzke89/quiz-can-you-tell...
An explanation of the tactics https://www.nytimes.com/video/opinion/100000006188102/what-i...
So yeah whatever, say it's not happening, based on all the evidence that having complete access to the site gives you. I don't believe you. I just know, deep down, based on my limited unprivileged access and my casual analysis of a small part of the content, that anyone who disagrees with my fundamental beliefs on here is a total shill.
And you know what? It's getting worse lately.
Ballpark, I'd estimate 1% of comments on sensitive topics, but 20% of votes on these topics are done with purpose of intentionally misleading the public.
Joking aside, I believe that the minimum standard for a "influence operation" is where "operators" use a greater number of sock puppet accounts in a centrally coordinated manner to dominate the discussion forum. There has to be deception: pretending to be multiple people.
If I ever see activity that appears to meet that standard I'll report my evidence of it to the admins, trust they will take appropriate action if necessary, and continue to assume everyone who doesn't agree with me is a reasonable person acting in good faith.
If an intelligence agency was directly posting false or misleading information on HN for the purposes of influencing readers, presumably if HN mods found evidence of this they would try to restrict it to the extent possible.
The much more challenging issue is that once a propaganda meme has taken hold in a normal citizen, they will also spread these ideas. This creates a nearly-impossible to moderate situation where a percentage of the population sincerely holds a belief and chooses to spread it.
For example: in recent threads about the release of Snowdens book, there were some comments that presented ideas as fact which are contradicted by publicly available evidence. I think it is fair to call this 'propaganda', in the sense that many of these ideas were likely deliberately crafted by intelligence orgs at inception, but these is no actionable moderation that can occur to prevent it. Impossible to tell if someone spreading an incorrect fact is doing so out of sincere belief or ulterior motive.
I agree that it seems like more propaganda has been appearing on HN in the past couple years, but sadly I think it is impossible to do anything to prevent it.
True, the Rust shills are ruthless :-)
0: https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2019/02/18/private-mossad...
Except they weren't billionaires then. More like thousandaires. And instead of buying, they just started a new one.
You mean like the way certain east (and probably west) coast billionaires spending millions to influence elections in the flyover states?
Now there could be many of reasons for that absence of news. Media could be constrained by gov. More likely is social networks being forced to keep silent. Soft power of / direct access to those US companies might be good enough for US intelligence to not warrant further actions risking trust in the platforms. Actions might take place on battlefields far away & not observed by western media (like, how would you even start getting around e.g. ID requirements in china... seems kind of hard).
Anyway, I just found noteworthy how well this one fits US geopolitical interests.
https://www.google.com/search?q=samsung+paid+students+for+re...
Happens on Reddit all the time once you know how to notice it, e.g. posts about the same topic on multiple subreddits getting over 10,000 upvotes in less than 3 hours, sometimes more than there are users of that subreddit!
https://www.reddit.com/r/videos/comments/bb7t71/reddit_for_s...
Bonus points when you don't even know who he is, because his money has been laundered through a PAC. Oh, and we get to subsidize his speech, because it's tax-deductible for him.
Double bonus points if, in a slightly different situation, that billionaire has been borrowing money for his various business ventures from friends of the Kremlin, and happens to look a wee bit orange...
At the time these rules were enacted, TV stations didn't want to carry political ads, and hardly any would accept them. The enforced rate structure was devised not only to encourage TV stations to carry political ads, but to ensure that a party with deeper pockets didn't drown out less-well-funded opinions.
When I worked in TV, the sales department hated political season because their bonuses got slashed.
A couple of economic crises later, and TV stations look forward to political ads because they it turns out they are more stable, reliable, and often pay in advance. The old standby for TV ads, car dealers, turned out to be not-so-reliable after all, especially with the automaker bankruptcies and people keeping cars longer.
With a bird in the hand worth two in the bush, we now have political ads out the wazoo.
And there should be facilities in place to punish those who push knowingly false narratives, but that's a damn-near impossible task to achieve.
The power of the censors was absolute: no magistrate could oppose their decisions, only another censor who succeeded them could cancel it.
The censors' regulation of public morality is the origin of the modern meaning of the words censor and censorship."
> The accounts, which have now been taken down, appear to have been professionally run by PR firms
These aren't real users and presumably violate the terms of service.
And your first reaction is "this could be/ must be Russia"? Do you realize Russia running a propaganda campaign for Saudi Arabia doesn't make any sense? How could you even think of something so counter-intuitive and inconsequential?
https://www.facebook.com/DailyCupOfJane/
https://www.facebook.com/HistoryBites/
https://www.facebook.com/ThisExplainsThat/
https://www.facebook.com/WeOnlyHaveOneEarth/
[1] https://www.theisraelproject.org/socialmedia
"The Israel Project has developed a cutting edge production shop to inform the 21st century media and public conversation. Using videos, memes, infographics and other original productions – TIP is ensuring social media users know the truth about Israel and the Middle East."
"the Facebook page Cup of Jane. Serving the young women’s community, it has built up over 450,000 followers in that short time. ... Since then, we have launched multiple communities including HistoryBites for history fans, This Explains That for news junkies and We Only Have One Earth for environmentally-minded folks"
There is far far worse going on in West Papua then is going on in Iran or Qatar, but Buzzfeed chooses to write about them instead.
The FB press release clearly mentions Indonesia and West Papua but it's ignored yet again by the western press.
https://newsroom.fb.com/news/2019/10/removing-coordinated-in...
But being "banned" from FB is much better than quitting... I have zero temptation to go back, it requires no discipline at all, so I'm not complaining.
in truth of course the US government is doing exactly the same thing all the time, standard practice.